Journal Article

Numerics and subgrid‐scale modeling in large eddy simulations of stratocumulus clouds

Kaul, Colleen M., Pressel, Kyle G., Tan, Zhihong, Schneider, Tapio, Mishra, Siddhartha

2017

Overview

Stratocumulus clouds are the most common type of boundary layer cloud; their radiative effects strongly modulate climate. Large eddy simulations (LES) of stratocumulus clouds often struggle to maintain fidelity to observations because of the sharp gradients occurring at the entrainment interfacial layer at the cloud top. The challenge posed to LES by stratocumulus clouds is evident in the wide range of solutions found in the LES intercomparison based on the DYCOMS‐II field campaign, where simulated liquid water paths for identical initial and boundary conditions varied by a factor of nearly 12. Here we revisit the DYCOMS‐II RF01 case and show that the wide range of previous LES results can be realized in a single LES code by varying only the numerical treatment of the equations of motion and the nature of subgrid‐scale (SGS) closures. The simulations that maintain the greatest fidelity to DYCOMS‐II observations are identified. The results show that using weighted essentially non‐oscillatory (WENO) numerics for all resolved advective terms and no explicit SGS closure consistently produces the highest‐fidelity simulations. This suggests that the numerical dissipation inherent in WENO schemes functions as a high‐quality, implicit SGS closure for this stratocumulus case. Conversely, using oscillatory centered difference numerical schemes for momentum advection, WENO numerics for scalars, and explicitly modeled SGS fluxes consistently produces the lowest‐fidelity simulations. We attribute this to the production of anomalously large SGS fluxes near the cloud tops through the interaction of numerical error in the momentum field with the scalar SGS model. Key Points Fidelity of LES simulations of stratocumulus clouds depends on advection schemes and SGS closures WENO schemes without explicit SGS closures simulate stratocumulus well A simple model shows how advection schemes and SGS closures interact and affect cloud simulations

• Publisher: John Wiley & Sons, Inc,John Wiley and Sons Inc
• Subject: Advection / Atmospheric Processes / Boundary conditions / boundary layer clouds / Boundary Layer Processes / Boundary layers / Climate / Clouds / Clouds and Aerosols / Clouds and Cloud Feedbacks / Entrainment / Equations of motion / Gradients / Intercomparison / Large Eddy Simulation / Large eddy simulations / Modelling / Momentum / Numerical schemes / numerics / SGS models / Simulation / Solutions / stratocumulus / Stratocumulus clouds / Temperature / WENO