Journal Article

Evaluating the environmental impacts of dietary recommendations

Jong, Jessica C. Kiefte-de, Bosker, Thijs, de Koning, Arjan, Tukker, Arnold, Behrens, Paul, Rodrigues, João F. D.

2017

Overview

Dietary choices drive both health and environmental outcomes. Information on diets come from many sources, with nationally recommended diets (NRDs) by governmental or similar advisory bodies the most authoritative. Little or no attention is placed on the environmental impacts within NRDs. Here we quantify the impact of nation-specific NRDs, compared with an average diet in 37 nations, representing 64% of global population. We focus on greenhouse gases (GHGs), eutrophication, and land use because these have impacts reaching or exceeding planetary boundaries. We show that compared with average diets, NRDs in high-income nations are associated with reductions in GHG, eutrophication, and land use from 13.0 to 24.8%, 9.8 to 21.3%, and 5.7 to 17.6%, respectively. In upper-middle–income nations, NRDs are associated with slight decrease in impacts of 0.8–12.2%, 7.7–19.4%, and 7.2–18.6%. In poorer middle-income nations, impacts increase by 12.4–17.0%, 24.5–31.9%, and 8.8–14.8%. The reduced environmental impact in high-income countries is driven by reductions in calories (∼54% of effect) and a change in composition (∼46%). The increased environmental impacts of NRDs in low- and middle-income nations are associated with increased intake in animal products. Uniform adoption of NRDs across these nations would result in reductions of 0.19–0.53 Gt CO₂ eq·a−1, 4.32–10.6 Gt PO 4 3 − eq·a−1, and 1.5–2.8 million km², while providing the health cobenefits of adopting an NRD. As a small number of dietary guidelines are beginning to incorporate more general environmental concerns, we anticipate that this work will provide a standardized baseline for future work to optimize recommended diets further.

• Publisher: National Academy of Sciences
• Subject: Animal products / Calories / Carbon dioxide / Composition effects / Conservation of Natural Resources - methods / Diet / Environmental impact / Environmental Sciences / Eutrophication / Greenhouse effect / Greenhouse Effect - prevention & control / Greenhouse gases / Guidelines as Topic / Humans / Income / International Cooperation / Land use / Nations / Physical Sciences / Recommended Dietary Allowances - economics / Social Sciences / Sustainability Science