Journal Article

Criminal justice policy transfer to post-Soviet states: two case studies of police reform in Russia and Ukraine

Robertson, Annette

2005

نظرة عامة

The aim of this article is to review the impact of two British research projects on the policies and practices of local police forces in two former Soviet states: Russia and Ukraine. Using a case study approach, the article explores the ways in which the political, cultural and ideological context within which the police operate, and reform is being attempted, shape attitudes towards reform amongst the police and the public, and the outcomes achieved. The article draws upon an evaluation of the impact of two independent 3-year applied research projects, which aimed to investigate specific crime and policing issues in Russia and Ukraine, implement pilot projects and evaluate their impact in order to make recommendations for more general criminal justice policy reform. The overall results of the projects suggest that, despite significant interest in the concept of police reform and the adoption of western concepts, particularly at the local level, significant barriers to large-scale policy transfer persist, many of which are largely beyond the influence of local practitioners and western reformers. Reprinted by permission of Springer

• موضوع: Case studies / Criminal justice / Criminology / European Union / Police / Post-Soviet studies / Reform / Russian Federation / Ukraine