Journal Article

Extremely high levels of PBDEs in children’s toys from European markets: causes and implications for the circular economy

Olisah, Chijioke, Pribylova, Petra, Melymuk, Lisa, Boudot, Martin, Kukucka, Petr, Audy, Ondrej

2024

Overview

Background With the high influx of low-cost plastic toys on the market, there is growing concern about the safety of such toys. Some of these plastic toys contains hazardous chemicals like polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) due to the use of recycled plastics in new toy manufacturing. Here, we investigated if toys marketed in Europe are compliant with EU directives to assess the safety of currently used children's toys and identify implications of PBDE content in toys. Results Eighty-four toys purchased from international toy retailers were screened for bromine using X-ray fluorescence (XRF), and 11 of those with bromine content higher than 500 µg/g were analyzed for ten PBDEs using GC–HRMS. PBDEs were detected in all 11 toys. Ʃ 10 PBDE concentrations ranged up to 23.5 mg/g (with a median concentration of 8.61 mg/g), with BDE-209 being the most abundant compound (4.40 mg/g). Eight samples exceeded the EU’s Low POP Content Limit (LPCL) of 500 µg/g for the Ʃ 10 PBDEs by 6–47 times and the Unintentional Trace Contaminant (UTC) limits of 10 µg/g for Deca-BDE by 12–800 times. Conclusions PBDEs were up to percent levels, suggesting direct recycling of flame retarded plastic, e.g., e-waste plastics, into toy components. This is a call for concern and requires intervention from all stakeholders involved in the toy market. Overall, the occurrence of non-compliant toys in the EU market, as indicated in this study is primarily attributed to gaps in regulations, inadequate legislation for recycled plastics, the rise of online sales, complexities in global and national supply chains, and economic challenges. Failure to address these issues will hinder the efforts of the plastics industry to transition into a circular economy. This suggests that more actions are needed to address gaps in cross-border enforcement, and stricter sanctions are required for toy manufacturers who fail to adhere to regulations and safety standards.

• Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg,Springer Nature B.V,SpringerOpen
• Subject: biphenyl / Bromine / Circular economy / Compliance / Consumer products / Contaminants / decabromodiphenyl ether / E-waste / Earth and Environmental Science / Economic conditions / Ecotoxicology / Electronic waste / electronic wastes / Enforcement / Environment / Ethers / Europe / Flame retardants / fluorescence / Industrial safety / industry / laws and regulations / Legislation / markets / Plastic debris / Plastic recycling / Plastics / Plastics industry / Pollution / Polybrominated diphenyl ethers / Recycled materials / Regulations / Safety / stakeholders / Supply chains / Toy industry / Toys / Trace contaminants / X-radiation / X-ray fluorescence