Journal Article

A (More) Systematic Exploration of the Trade Effect of Product-Specific Rules of Origin

Gourdon, Julien, de Melo, Jaime, Gourdon, Karin

2023

Overview

Rules of Origin (RoO) are critical components of Preferential Trade Agreements (PTAs). They are designed to stop products coming into a PTA through the partner that applies the lowest tariff – a phenomenon known as trade deflection. While RoO are necessary, complex RoO may undo the benefits of trade agreements. Using a novel database of RoO, this paper evaluates the incidence and restrictiveness of different types of Product-Specific Rules of Origin (PSRs) across 128 reciprocal PTAs for the period 1990–2015. Results, based on a structural gravity model controlling for confounding factors, display wide heterogeneity across different categories of PSRs attached to preferential margins, with more flexible PSRs associated with a significantly stronger trade effect compared to more restrictive ones where exporters do not have a choice among PSRs or have to satisfy multiple PSRs. A simulation exercise reveals that a radical simplification reform leading to the adoption of flexible PSRs providing alternative choices to prove origin would have increased global trade under PTAs on average by between 2.7 and 4% during the sample period.

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Subject: Classification / Compliance / Estimates / General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade / International trade / North American Free Trade Agreement (1992 December 17) / Original Article / Preferential Trade and Regional Integration / Production costs / Rule of origin / Simulation / Tariffs / Trade agreements