Journal Article

Randomization in the age of platform trials: unexplored challenges and some potential solutions

Bodden, Daniel, Jacko, Peter, Ross, Jennifer, Robertson, David S., Cooner, Freda, Chipman, Jonathan, Sverdlov, Oleksandr, Luo, Yuqun Abigail, Krisam, Johannes, Villar, Sofia S., Mielke, Tobias, Kuznetsova, Olga, Ryeznik, Yevgen, Zhao, Wenle

2025

Overview

While platform trials have several benefits with their adaptive features, randomization challenges become of central relevance to the design and execution of a platform trial. This paper intends to address these challenges and explore some potential solutions. A platform type of clinical trial is a clinical trial design where multiple interventions are investigated simultaneously often against partly or fully shared controls, with new treatment arms added and completed treatment arms removed. Unequal allocation is often used in platform trials to improve statistical efficiency, deliver benefits to trial participants, and control the speed of enrollment in different treatment arms. Changes to the allocation ratio may be required after an interim analysis even when the number of treatment arms remains constant, for example, in a platform trial with response-adaptive randomization. To deliver the design efficiencies promised by the carefully optimized allocation ratio or simply to ensure a pre-determined allocation ratio, randomization methods that keep allocation proportions close to the target allocation ratio throughout randomization are helpful. Other situations commonly occurring in platform trials require special considerations for randomization methods and in some cases new classes of randomization methods. Such specific platform features include the requirement to accommodate differences in eligibility for different treatments, the need to ensure partial blinding with a 2-step randomization when mode of administration for different interventions is conspicuously different and full blinding is unfeasible, the objective to balance through dynamic randomization multiple prognostic factors or the need to accommodate limited drug supplies at the numerous trial centers, among others. The key to a successful execution of a complex randomization in the platform trial is the expert design of the Interactive Response Technology (IRT) system, where the system is built at the master protocol level and existing and potential randomization needs are incorporated from the outset. An additional, often overlooked, challenge when working with unequal allocation ratios and randomization methods to attain these, is the importance of preserving the unconditional allocation ratio at every allocation. Failure to do so might lead to a selection and evaluation bias even in double-blind trials, accidental bias, and reduced power of the re-randomization test.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adaptive design / Clinical trials / COVID-19 / Decision making / Efficiency / Health Sciences / Humans / Medical research / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Medicine, Experimental / Methods / Platform trial / Product development / Prostate cancer / R&D / Random Allocation / Randomization / Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic - methods / Ratios / Research & development / Research Design / Review / Statistical Theory and Methods / Statistics for Life Sciences / Theory of Medicine/Bioethics / Unequal allocation