Journal Article

Cartilage tissue turnover increases with high- compared to low-intensity resistance training in patients with knee OA

De Zwart, Arjan, van der Leeden, Marike, Bay-Jensen, Anne-Christine, van Spil, Willem Evert, Jansen, Nuria, Lems, Willem, Van der Esch, Martin, Roorda, Leo, Engstrøm, Amalie, Frederiksen, Peder, Thudium, Christian S., Dekker, Joost

2023

Overview

Objectives To investigate cartilage tissue turnover in response to a supervised 12-week exercise-related joint loading training program followed by a 6-month period of unsupervised training in patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA). To study the difference in cartilage tissue turnover between high- and low-resistance training. Method Patients with knee OA were randomized into either high-intensity or low-intensity resistance supervised training (two sessions per week) for 3 months and unsupervised training for 6 months. Blood samples were collected before and after the supervised training period and after the follow-up period. Biomarkers huARGS, C2M, and PRO-C2, quantifying cartilage tissue turnover, were measured by ELISA. Changes in biomarker levels over time within and between groups were analyzed using linear mixed models with baseline values as covariates. Results huARGS and C2M levels increased after training and at follow-up in both low- and high-intensity exercise groups. No changes were found in PRO-C2. The huARGS level in the high-intensity resistance training group increased significantly compared to the low-intensity resistance training group after resistance training ( p = 0.029) and at follow-up ( p = 0.003). Conclusion Cartilage tissue turnover and cartilage degradation appear to increase in response to a 3-month exercise-related joint loading training program and at 6-month follow-up, with no evident difference in type II collagen formation. Aggrecan remodeling increased more with high-intensity resistance training than with low-intensity exercise. These exploratory biomarker results, indicating more cartilage degeneration in the high-intensity group, in combination with no clinical outcome differences of the VIDEX study, may argue against high-intensity training.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Aggrecans - metabolism / Arthritis / Biomarkers / Care and treatment / Cartilage / Cartilage, Articular - metabolism / Collagen / Comparative analysis / Exercise therapy / Extracellular matrix / Health aspects / Humans / Knee / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Methods / Orthopedics / Osteoarthritis / Osteoarthritis, Knee - metabolism / Physiological aspects / Resistance Training / Rheumatology / Strength training