Journal Article

Evaluating nanopore sequencing data processing pipelines for structural variation identification

Zhou, Anbo, Xing, Jinchuan, Lin, Timothy

2019

Overview

Background Structural variations (SVs) account for about 1% of the differences among human genomes and play a significant role in phenotypic variation and disease susceptibility. The emerging nanopore sequencing technology can generate long sequence reads and can potentially provide accurate SV identification. However, the tools for aligning long-read data and detecting SVs have not been thoroughly evaluated. Results Using four nanopore datasets, including both empirical and simulated reads, we evaluate four alignment tools and three SV detection tools. We also evaluate the impact of sequencing depth on SV detection. Finally, we develop a machine learning approach to integrate call sets from multiple pipelines. Overall SV callers’ performance varies depending on the SV types. For an initial data assessment, we recommend using aligner minimap2 in combination with SV caller Sniffles because of their speed and relatively balanced performance. For detailed analysis, we recommend incorporating information from multiple call sets to improve the SV call performance. Conclusions We present a workflow for evaluating aligners and SV callers for nanopore sequencing data and approaches for integrating multiple call sets. Our results indicate that additional optimizations are needed to improve SV detection accuracy and sensitivity, and an integrated call set can provide enhanced performance. The nanopore technology is improving, and the sequencing community is likely to grow accordingly. In turn, better benchmark call sets will be available to more accurately assess the performance of available tools and facilitate further tool development.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Animal Genetics and Genomics / Benchmarking / Benchmarking Studies / Bioinformatics / Biomedical and Life Sciences / data collection / Datasets / disease susceptibility / Evolutionary Biology / genome / Genomes / Genomic Structural Variation / Genomics - methods / Human Genetics / Humans / Life Sciences / Machine learning / Microbial Genetics and Genomics / Nanopore sequencing / Nanopores / phenotypic variation / Phenotypic variations / Pipeline evaluation / Plant Genetics and Genomics / Sequence Alignment - methods / Sequence Analysis, DNA / Single-molecule sequencing / Structural variation