Journal Article

Transparency ethics in practice: Revisiting financial conflicts of interest disclosure forms in clinical practice guidelines

Subramanian, Venkataraman, McQuaid, Kenneth, Jones, Derek J., Laine, Loren, Lu, Yidan, Sharara, Nour, Soetikno, Roy, Barkun, Alan, Kaltenbach, Tonya

2017

Overview

Authors of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) disclose financial conflicts of interest (FCOIs) to promote transparency ethics. Typically, they do so on standard declaration forms containing generic open-ended questions on FCOIs. Yet, the literature is scant on the format and effect of alternative disclosure forms. Does supplementing a standard form with subsequent detailed disclosure forms tailored to the context of the CPG improve the yield or accuracy of FCOIs declarations? For an international CPG in gastroenterology on the endoscopic surveillance for colorectal neoplasia in inflammatory bowel disease, we compared the use of a standard FCOIs disclosure form with a contextual FCOIs disclosure form that detailed commercial relations related to the CPG topic. This included manufacturers of endoscopes, endoscopy equipment and accessories. Participants completed the generic form early, and the supplementary contextual form six months later. We then compared the FCOI disclosures obtained. 26 participants provided FCOIs disclosures using both disclosure forms. We found discrepancies regarding (1) the disclosure of FCOIs (presence/absence), and (2) the listing of financial entities. While the number of participants who disclosed a FCOI remained the same (30.8%) using the two forms, disclosures were not from the same individuals: two additional participants disclosed a FCOI, whereas two participants withdrew previous disclosures. Among those who reported a FCOI in either form, we noted inconsistencies in disclosures for 70% of the participants. This included changes in FCOIs disclosure status or modifications of \"their commercial relations\". Accurate reporting of FCOIs advances the transparency and ethical integrity of CPGs. Our experience suggests that a contextual FCOIs disclosure form tailored to content of the CPG with narrow, detailed questions provides supplementary, more complete FCOIs declarations than generic forms alone. The finding raises challenges on how forms are best written and formatted, optimally timed, and more effectively processed with sensitivity to professional behaviour, so as to heighten transparency.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Accreditation / Analysis / Biology and Life Sciences / Clinical medicine / Clinical practice guidelines / Colorectal cancer / Conflict of Interest / Conflicts of interest / Economic aspects / Endoscopes / Endoscopy / Ethical aspects / Ethical standards / Ethics / Ethics, Professional / Financial disclosure / Financial Management / Gastroenterology / Guidelines / Health education / Inflammatory bowel diseases / Intestine / Jones, Alan / Medical research / Medicine / Medicine and Health Sciences / Physicians / Practice guidelines (Medicine) / Practice Guidelines as Topic / Research and Analysis Methods / Social Sciences / Transparency / Veterans