Journal Article

Assessment of salivary microRNA by RT-qPCR: Facing challenges in data interpretation for clinical diagnosis

Cardinal, Anna, Ouedraogo, Alimata, Molina, Franck, Lepeltier, Morgane, Boulestreau, Jérémy, Champigneux, Pierre, Van Der Hofstadt, Marc, Van, Thi Nhu Ngoc, Kahli, Malik, Molina, Laurence

2024

Overview

Salivary microRNAs (miRNAs) have been recently revealed as the next generation of non-invasive biomarkers for the diagnostics of diverse diseases. However, their short and highly homologous sequences make their quantification by RT-qPCR technique highly heterogeneous and study dependent, thus limiting their implementation for clinical applications. In this study, we evaluated the use of a widely used commercial RT-qPCR kit for quantification of salivary miRNAs for clinical diagnostics. Saliva from ten healthy volunteers were sampled four times within a three month time course and submitted for small RNA extraction followed by RT-qPCR analysed. Six miRNAs with different sequence homologies were analysed. Sensitivity and specificity of the tested miRNA assays were corroborated using synthetic miRNAs to evaluate the reliability of all tested assays. Significant variabilities in expression profiles of six miRNAs from ten healthy participants were revealed, yet the poor specificity of the assays offered insufficient performance to associate these differences to biological context. Indeed, as the limit of quantification (LOQ) concentrations are from 2–4 logs higher than that of the limit of detection (LOD) ones, the majority of the analysis for salivary miRNAs felt outside the quantification region. Most importantly, a remarkable number of crosstalk reactions exhibiting considerable OFF target signal intensities was detected, indicating their poor specificity and limited reliability. However, the spike-in of synthetic target miRNA increased the capacity to discriminate endogenous salivary miRNA at the LOQ concentrations from those that were significantly lower. Our results demonstrate that comparative analyses for salivary miRNA expression profiles by this commercial RT-qPCR kit are most likely associated to technical limitations rather than to biological differences. While further technological breakthroughs are still required to overcome discrepancies, standardization of rigorous sample handling and experimental design according to technical parameters of each assay plays a crucial role in reducing data inconsistencies across studies.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Adolescent / Adult / Assaying / Biological effects / Biology and life sciences / Biomarkers / Biomarkers - analysis / Clinical medicine / Comparative analysis / Data interpretation / Data reduction / Design of experiments / Design standards / Experimental design / Gene expression / Genetic aspects / Health aspects / Healthy Volunteers / Homology / Humans / Life Sciences / Limit of Detection / Male / Medical diagnosis / Medicine and Health Sciences / Methods / MicroRNA / MicroRNAs / MicroRNAs - analysis / MicroRNAs - metabolism / miRNA / Nucleotide sequence / Performance evaluation / Reagent Kits, Diagnostic / Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction - instrumentation / Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction - methods / Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction - standards / Reliability / Reproducibility of Results / Research and analysis methods / Reverse transcriptase / Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction - instrumentation / Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction - methods / Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction - standards / Saliva / Saliva - chemistry / Saliva - metabolism / Salivary diagnostics / Sensitivity analysis / Sensitivity and Specificity / Software / Statistical analysis / Target detection / Thermal cycling / Viscosity / Young Adult