Paper

First, do NOHARM: towards clinically safe large language models

Maharaj, Saloni Kumar, Liang, April S, Ranji, Sumant, Chopra, Kanav, Newman, Kira L, Weng, Yingjie, Hong, David I, Kadiyala, Vinay, Badhwar, Adi, Koh, Joel, McCoy, Liam G, Hom, Jason, Koshy, Jacob M, Ziolkowski, Susan, Goh, Ethan, Cosgriff, Christopher V, Gwiazdon, Matthew, Bassman Tappuni, Rodman, Adam, Agarwal, Anup, Buchheit, Kathleen M, Caldwell, Jillian, Khemani, Sarita, Rustagi, Arjun, Dalal, Rahul S, Chen, Jonathan H, Milstein, Arnold, Diep, Robert, Jesudasen, Sirus, Shirvani, Daniel, Chakraborty, Rebanta, Shah, Nigam H, Pahalyants, Vartan, Patil, Advait, Iberri, David J, Wei, Nancy, Ravi, Vishnu, Jindal, Jenelle, Shih, Allen, Kaplan, Tamara B, Pallais, J Carl, Schulman, Kevin, Tran, Jessica, Wu, David J H, Wu, David, Fateme Nateghi Haredasht, Lee, Ernest Y, Jain, Priyank, Marshall, Nicholas, Galetta, Kristin, French, Brianna

2025

Overview

Large language models (LLMs) are routinely used by physicians and patients for medical advice, yet their clinical safety profiles remain poorly characterized. We present NOHARM (Numerous Options Harm Assessment for Risk in Medicine), a benchmark using 100 real primary care-to-specialist consultation cases to measure frequency and severity of harm from LLM-generated medical recommendations. NOHARM covers 10 specialties, with 12,747 expert annotations for 4,249 clinical management options. Across 31 LLMs, potential for severe harm from LLM recommendations occurs in up to 22.2% (95% CI 21.6-22.8%) of cases, with harm of omission accounting for 76.6% (95% CI 76.4-76.8%) of errors. Safety performance is only moderately correlated (r = 0.61-0.64) with existing AI and medical knowledge benchmarks. The best models outperform generalist physicians on safety (mean difference 9.7%, 95% CI 7.0-12.5%), and a diverse multi-agent approach improves safety compared to solo models (mean difference 8.0%, 95% CI 4.0-12.1%). Therefore, despite strong performance on existing evaluations, widely used AI models can produce severely harmful medical advice at nontrivial rates, underscoring clinical safety as a distinct performance dimension necessitating explicit measurement.

• Publisher: Cornell University Library, arXiv.org
• Subject: Annotations / Benchmarks / Large language models / Multiagent systems / Performance evaluation / Physicians