Journal Article

Effectiveness of subsurface pressure monitoring for brine leakage detection in an uncertain CO sub(2) sequestration system

Small, Mitchell J, Azzolina, Nicholas A, Nakles, David V, Bromhal, Grant S

2014

Overview

This work evaluates the detection sensitivity of deep subsurface pressure monitoring within an uncertain carbon dioxide sequestration system by linking the output of an analytical reduced-order model and first-order uncertainty analysis. A baseline (non-leaky) modeling run was compared against 10 different leakage scenarios, where the cap rock permeability was increased by factors of 2-100 (cap rock permeability from 10 super(-3) to 10 super(-1) millidarcy). The uncertainty variance outputs were used to develop percentile estimates and detection sensitivity for pressure throughout the deep subsurface as a function of space (lateral distance from the injection wells and vertical orientation within the reservoir) and time (years since injection), or P(x, z, t). Conditional probabilities were computed for combinations of x, z, and t, which were then used to generate power curves for detecting leakage scenarios. The results suggest that measurements of the absolute change in pressure within the target injection aquifer would not be able to distinguish small leakage rates (i.e., less than 50 baseline) from baseline conditions, and that only large leakage rates (i.e., >100 baseline) would be discriminated with sufficient statistical power (>99 %). Combining measurements, for example by taking the ratio of formation pressure in Aquifer 2/Aquifer 1, provides better statistical power for distinguishing smaller leakage rates at earlier times in the injection program. Detection sensitivity for pressure is a function of space and time. Therefore, design of an adequate monitoring network for subsurface pressure should account for this space-time variability to ensure that the monitoring system performs to the necessary design criteria, e.g., specific false-negative and false-positive rates.