Journal Article

Autonomy, age and sterilisation requests

McQueen, Paddy

2017

Overview

Sterilisation requests made by young, child-free adults are frequently denied by doctors, despite sterilisation being legally available to individuals over the age of 18. A commonly given reason for denied requests is that the patient will later regret their decision. In this paper, I examine whether the possibility of future regret is a good reason for denying a sterilisation request. I argue that it is not and hence that decision-competent adults who have no desire to have children should have their requests approved. It is a condition of being recognised as autonomous that a person ought to be permitted to make decisions that they might later regret, provided that their decision is justified at the time that it is made. There is also evidence to suggest that sterilisation requests made by men are more likely to be approved than requests made by women, even when age and number of children are factored in. This may indicate that attitudes towards sterilisation are influenced by gender discourses that define women in terms of reproduction and mothering. If this is the case, then it is unjustified and should be addressed. There is no good reason to judge people's sterilisation requests differently in virtue of their gender.

• Publisher: BMJ Publishing Group Ltd,BMJ Publishing Group LTD
• Subject: Adolescent / Adults / Age / Age Factors / Attitudes / Autonomy / Birth control / Children / Children & youth / Choice Behavior - ethics / Clinical ethics / Consent / Decision making / Decision Making - ethics / Decisions / Discourses / Elective Surgical Procedures - ethics / Elective Surgical Procedures - psychology / Emotions / Female / Gender / Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice / Humans / Morality / Mothers / Personal Autonomy / Physician's Role / Physicians / Refusal to Treat - ethics / Regret / Reproductive Behavior - ethics / Reproductive Behavior - psychology / Sterilization / Sterilization, Tubal - ethics / Sterilization, Tubal - psychology / Sterilization, Tubal - statistics & numerical data / Women / Young Adult / Young adults