Journal Article

Questionnaire survey on women’s views after a first caesarean delivery in two tertiary centres in Ireland and their preference for involvement in a future randomised trial on mode of birth

McAuliffe, Fionnuala, Devane, Declan, O Doherty, Kate C, Morrison, John, Ryan, Gillian

2019

Overview

ObjectiveTo assess the views of women after a first caesarean section (CS) on their birth experience, preference for future mode of birth and willingness to participate in a randomised controlled trial on mode of birth in a future pregnancy.DesignQuestionnaire survey.SettingTwo tertiary maternity centres Ireland, Galway University Hospital, Galwayand the National Maternity Hospital, Dublin.ParticipantsWomen with one previous CS.MethodsEligible women consented to participate, and postal surveys were forwarded. Results were collected and analysed. Results were compared between women who had elective operations and women who had emergency operations.Primary outcome measuresThe satisfaction levels of women after a first caesarean, their preference for mode of birth in a future pregnancy and their willingness to participate in a randomised trial on mode of birth.ResultsThere were 347 completed surveys of 633 women who consented to participate (54.8%), of whom 285 and 62 had emergency and elective caesarean deliveries, respectively. In general, satisfaction ratings with the delivery were greater than 90%, with similar levels of satisfaction with the care received from doctors and midwives. Women who an emergency procedure expressed lower satisfaction levels with the information about the caesarean and the debriefing received afterwards than women who had a planned operation (p<0.05). For future mode of birth, 39.5% expressed a preference for vaginal birth after caesarean (VBAC) in a subsequent pregnancy, and 80% said they would consider involvement in a randomised trial in a future pregnancy.ConclusionDebriefing and counselling women after a CS is an important part of pregnancy care and can significantly impact on a woman’s overall birth experience. A significant proportion of this cohort considered VBAC as a future birth option. These data indicate that a randomised trial on mode of birth after caesarean would be viewed positively by women in our population.

• Publisher: British Medical Journal Publishing Group,BMJ Publishing Group LTD,BMJ Publishing Group
• Subject: Adult / birth preference after caesarean / caesarean section / Cesarean section / Cesarean Section - psychology / Childbirth & labor / Elective Surgical Procedures - psychology / Emergencies / Female / Health Care Surveys / Health risk assessment / Humans / Ireland / maternal medicine / Obstetrics and Gynaecology / Patient Participation / Patient Preference - statistics & numerical data / Patient Selection / randomised trial on mode of birth / Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic / Surveys and Questionnaires / Tertiary Care Centers / vaginal birth after caesarean / Vaginal Birth after Cesarean - statistics & numerical data / Womens health