Journal Article

A targeted promotional DVD fails to improve Māori and Pacific participation rates in the New Zealand bowel screening pilot: results from a pseudo-randomised controlled trial

Sandiford, Peter, Bartholomew, Karen, Crengle, Sue, Zhou, Lifeng, Buswell, Elizabeth, Buckley, Anne

2019

Overview

Background New Zealand’s Bowel Screening Pilot (BSP) used a mailed invitation to return a faecal immunochemical test. As a pilot it offered opportunities to test interventions for reducing ethnic inequities in colorectal cancer screening prior to nationwide programme introduction. Small media interventions (e.g. educational material and DVDs) have been used at both community and participant level to improve uptake. We tested whether a DVD originally produced to raise community awareness among the Māori population would have a positive impact on participation and reduce the proportion of incorrectly performed tests (spoiled kits) if mailed out with the usual reminder letter. Methods The study was a parallel groups pseudo-randomised controlled trial. Over 12 months, all Māori and Pacific ethnicity non-responders four weeks after being mailed the test kit were allocated on alternate weeks to be sent, or not, the DVD intervention with the usual reminder letter. The objective was to determine changes in participation and spoiled kit rates in each ethnic group, determined three months from the date the reminder letter was sent. Participants and those recording the outcomes (receipt of a spoiled or non-spoiled test kit) were blinded to group assignment. Results 2333 Māori and 2938 Pacific people participated (11 withdrew). Those who were sent the DVD (1029 Māori and 1359 Pacific) were less likely to participate in screening than those who were not (1304 Māori and 1579 Pacific). Screening participation was reduced by 12.3% (95% CI 9.1–15.5%) in Māori (13.6% versus 25.9%) and 8.3% (95% CI 5.8–10.8%) in Pacific (10.1% versus 18.4%). However, spoiled kit rates (first return) were significantly higher among those not sent the DVD (33.1% versus 12.4% in Māori and 42.1% versus 21.9% in Pacific). Conclusion The DVD sent with the reminder letter to BSP non-responders reduced screening participation to an extent that more than offset the lower rate of spoiled kits. Trial registration Australia and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12612001259831 . Registered 30 November 2013.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Aged / Biostatistics / Bowel cancer screening / Cancer / Cancer screening / Clinical trials / Colorectal cancer / Colorectal Neoplasms - ethnology / Demographic aspects / Diagnosis / Environmental Health / Epidemiology / Ethnic factors / Ethnicity / Evaluation / Faecal immunochemical test / Female / Health aspects / Health behavior / Health promotion / Health Promotion - methods / health promotion and society / Health services / Humans / Intervention / Intestine / Male / Maori (New Zealand people) / Marketing / Mass Screening - statistics & numerical data / Medical screening / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Methods / Middle Aged / Minority & ethnic groups / Māori / New Zealand / Optical disks / Pacific / Pacific Islanders / Participation / Pilot Projects / Population / Program Evaluation / Public Health / Public participation / Randomization / Recording / Research Article / Small media interventions / Vaccine