Journal Article

The relativity of perspective: exploring the disconnect between Indigenous and Western paradigms of disaster risk perception

Magadza, Tsitsi Trina, Coetzee, Christo, Kruger, Leandri

2024

Overview

PurposeThis article demonstrates how psycho-sociological concepts have a place in disaster risk sciences. It draws attention to the relationship between risk perception and disaster management from Western and traditional viewpoints.Design/methodology/approachThis paper is conceptual and draws from published works. The systematic literature review (SLR) methodology was adopted to analyse existing literature on the subject matter.FindingsRisk perception evolved over centuries and disciplines until it found applicability in modern times. Despite the proliferation of western science-based approaches to risk perception, Indigenous knowledge systems still hold sway over communities’ understanding of risk. These perspectives are enshrined in religious and cultural convictions that become the lenses through which a society assigns cause, effect and remedy to risk events. A deeper understanding of these convictions enables disaster risk management strategies to be better accepted by those at risk and to align with their lived realities.Originality/valueRisk perception becomes the lens through which we better understand the realities and complexities of populations at risk. Indigenous knowledge systems have a strong influence on society’s perception of risk and if they are not harnessed and studied, they will stand in conflict with Western approaches. Hence, the study of the nexus between risk perception and disaster management presents an opportunity for policymakers and practitioners to design risk management solutions that have a higher chance of acceptance and sustainability.

• Publisher: Emerald Publishing Limited,Emerald Group Publishing Limited
• Subject: Disaster management / Disaster risk / Disasters / Emergency preparedness / Greek civilization / Indigenous knowledge / Indigenous Peoples' knowledge / Literature reviews / Perception / Perceptions / Philosophers / Population studies / Relativity / Risk management / Risk perception / Sustainability