Journal Article

Embedded Revisionism: Networks, Institutions, and Challenges to World Order

Goddard, Stacie E.

2018

Overview

How do institutions shape revisionist behavior in world politics? Applying a network-relational approach to revisionist states and challenges to institutional order, I conceive of institutions as networks—as patterns of ongoing social transactions in which revisionists are embedded. Revisionist behavior is shaped by how a state is positioned within this existing network of institutions. A state's position significantly influences the material and cultural resources the state can deploy in pursuit of its aims, and thus the revisionist's strategy. Focusing on two measures of network position—access and brokerage—I propose four ideal types of revisionists and their strategies in the international system: integrated revisionists, who are likely to pursue institutional engagement; bridging revisionists, who will seek rule-based revolution; isolated revisionists, who prefer to exit the institutional system; and rogue revisionists, who have few resources at hand, and thus ultimately must resort to hegemonic violence. I test these ideal types in four cases of revisionists and institutional orders: Russia in the 1820s; Prussia in the 1860s; the Soviet Union in the early Cold War; and Japan in the 1920s and 1930s.

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press,Cambridge University Press for the IO Foundation
• Subject: 19th century / Brokerage / Cold War / Cultural factors / Cultural resources / Hegemony / Ideal types / Institutions / International relations / Politics / Power / Revisionism / Social networks / Stock brokers / Transactions / Violence / World order