Journal Article

Incorporating healthcare access and equity in economic evaluations: a scoping review of guidelines

Shinkins, Bethany, Jayne, David, Meads, David, Ensor, Tim, Dawkins, Bryony

2024

Overview

International development agendas increasingly push for access to healthcare for all through universal healthcare coverage. Health economic evaluations and health technology assessment (HTA) could provide evidence to support this but do not routinely incorporate consideration of equitable access. We undertook an international scoping review of health economic evaluation and HTA guidelines to examine how well issues of healthcare access and equity are represented, evidence recommendations, and gaps in current guidance to support evidence generation in this area. Guidelines were sourced from guideline repositories and websites of international agencies and organizations providing best practice methods guidance. Articles providing methods guidance for the conduct of HTA, or health economic evaluation, were included, except where they were not available in English and a suitable translation could not be obtained. The search yielded forty-seven national, four international, and nine independent guidelines, along with eighty-six articles providing specific methods guidance. The inclusion of equity and access considerations in current guidance is extremely limited. Where they do feature, detail on specific methods for providing evidence on these issues is sparse. Economic evaluation could be a valuable tool to provide evidence for the best healthcare strategies that not only maximize health but also ensure equitable access to care for all. Such evidence would be invaluable in supporting progress towards universal healthcare coverage. Clear guidance is required to ensure evaluations provide evidence on the best strategies to support equitable access to healthcare, but such guidance rarely exists in current best practice and guidance documents.

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Subject: Best practice / Cost analysis / Cost-Benefit Analysis / Decision making / Documents / Equity / Evaluation / Guidelines / Guidelines as Topic / Health care / Health care access / Health disparities / Health Equity / Health Services Accessibility / Health technology assessment / Healthcare Disparities / Humans / Method / Technology assessment / Technology Assessment, Biomedical - economics / Technology Assessment, Biomedical - organization & administration