Journal Article

Post-Mastectomy Breast Reconstruction Disparities: A Systematic Review of Sociodemographic and Economic Barriers

Chu, Michael, Carre, Antoine L., Chang, Jeff, Sam, Andre-Philippe, Vangsness, Kella L., Agko, Mouchammed, Munabi, Naikhoba, Juste, Jonathan

2024

Overview

Background: Breast reconstruction (BR) following mastectomy is a well-established beneficial medical intervention for patient physical and psychological well-being. Previous studies have emphasized BR as the gold standard of care for breast cancer patients requiring surgery. Multiple policies have improved BR access, but there remain social, economic, and geographical barriers to receiving reconstruction. Threats to equitable healthcare for all breast cancer patients in America persist despite growing awareness and efforts to negate these disparities. While race/ethnicity has been correlated with differences in BR rates and outcomes, ongoing research outlines a multitude of issues underlying this variance. Understanding the current and continuous barriers will help to address and overcome gaps in access. Methods: A systematic review assessing three reference databases (PubMed, Web of Science, and Ovid Medline) was carried out in accordance with PRISMA 2020 guidelines. A keyword search was conducted on 3 February 2024, specifying results between 2004 and 2024. Studies were included based on content, peer-reviewed status, and publication type. Two independent reviewers screened results based on title/abstract appropriateness and relevance. Data were extracted, cached in an online reference collection, and input into a cloud-based database for analysis. Results: In total, 1756 references were populated from all databases (PubMed = 829, Ovid Medline = 594, and Web of Science = 333), and 461 duplicate records were removed, along with 1147 results deemed ineligible by study criteria. Then, 45 international or non-English results were excluded. The screening sample consisted of 103 publications. After screening, the systematic review produced 70 studies with satisfactory relevance to our study focus. Conclusions: Federal mandates have improved access to women undergoing postmastectomy BR, particularly for younger, White, privately insured, urban-located patients. Recently published studies had a stronger focus on disparities, particularly among races, and show continued disadvantages for minorities, lower-income, rural-community, and public insurance payers. The research remains limited beyond commonly reported metrics of disparity and lacks examination of additional contributing factors. Future investigations should elucidate the effect of these factors and propose measures to eliminate barriers to access to BR for all patients.

• Publisher: MDPI AG
• Subject: African Americans / Breast cancer / Breast Neoplasms - surgery / breast reconstruction / Cancer therapies / Data collection / disparities / Female / Health care access / Health Services Accessibility - standards / Health Services Accessibility - statistics & numerical data / Healthcare Disparities - statistics & numerical data / Humans / Lumpectomy / Mammaplasty - economics / Mammaplasty - methods / Mammaplasty - statistics & numerical data / Mastectomy / Mastectomy - methods / Medicaid / Medical diagnosis / Minority & ethnic groups / Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act 2010-US / Patients / postmastectomy breast reconstruction / Public health / Sociodemographic Factors / Sociodemographics / Socioeconomic Factors / Surgery / Systematic review / Well being