Journal Article

Prior knowledge activation: how different concept mapping tasks lead to substantial differences in cognitive processes, learning outcomes, and perceived self-efficacy

Gurlitt, Johannes, Renkl, Alexander

2010

Overview

Two experiments investigated the effects of characteristic features of concept mapping used for prior knowledge activation. Characteristic demands of concept mapping include connecting lines representing the relationships between concepts and labeling these lines, specifying the type of the semantic relationships. In the first experiment, employing a within-subjects design, 20 psychology students completed a label-provided-lines economics mapping task and then a create-and-label-lines meteorology mapping task or vice versa. The analysis of 40 think-aloud protocols indicated more elaboration processes for the label-provided-lines task than for the create-and-label-lines task. On the other hand, the protocols indicated more model-construction and organization processes in the create-and-label-lines task. The second experiment used the same variation but focused on learning outcomes and perceived self-efficacy as dependent measures. Forty-two psychology students were randomly assigned to either a label-provided-lines mapping task or a create-and-label-lines mapping task. Subsequently, both groups completed a learning phase in a hypertext environment and a posttest. Results showed substantial differences in learning outcomes and perceived self-efficacy in favor of the label-provided-lines prior knowledge activation task. The findings are congruent with coherence effects found in text-comprehension research and support the position that concept mapping should not be seen as a unitary method but be differentiated according to the specific tasks to be completed.

• Publisher: Springer,Springer Netherlands,Springer Nature B.V
• Subject: Cognition / Cognition & reasoning / Cognitive Processes / Cognitive Structures / Coherence / College Students / Comprehension / Concept Mapping / Education / Educational environment / Educational Psychology / Elaboration / Experiments / Hypermedia / Hypertext / Inferences / Knowledge / Labeling / Learning / Learning and Instruction / Learning outcomes / Learning theory / Long Term Memory / Longitudinal Studies / Mapping / Mathematics Achievement / Metacognition / Meteorology / Outcomes of Education / Pedagogic Psychology / Perceptual learning / Prior knowledge / Prior Learning / Protocol Analysis / Psychology / Resistance (Psychology) / Science education / Self concept / Self Efficacy / Semantics / Students / Task Analysis / Teaching Methods