Journal Article

Semi-quantitative risk assessment of African swine fever virus introduction in pig farms

Bellini, Silvia, Valentini, Francesco, Calò, Stefania, Cappa, Veronica, Mannelli, Alessandro, Rusinà, Alessia, Scollo, Annalisa, Bellato, Alessandro, Alborali, Giovanni Loris, Franceschini, Giorgio

2023

Overview

A semi-quantitative risk assessment was developed to classify pig farms in terms of the probability of introduction of African swine fever virus (ASFV). Following on-farm data collection via a specific checklist, we applied a modified failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA) to calculate the risk priority codes (RPC's), indicating increasing risk levels ranging from 1 to 5. The importance of biosecurity measures was attributed by experts. To consider geographic risk factors, we classified pig farms based on local density of farmed pigs, and on the estimated wild boar population density. The combination of RPC's with geographical risk factors resulted into a final ranking of pig farms in terms of the risk of ASFV introduction. Furthermore, the estimation of frequency and levels of non-compliance with biosecurity measures was used to identify weak points in risk prevention at farm level. The outcome of the risk assessment was affected by choices in assigning non-compliance scores and importance to specific components of biosecurity. The method was applied in 60 commercial farms in major pig production areas in Italy. Furthermore, we applied a reduced version of our checklist in 12 non-commercial/small commercial (≤20 pigs) farms in the northern Apennines. In commercial farms, highest RPC's were obtained for biosecurity measures associated with personnel practices and farm buildings/planimetry. Intervention should be addressed to training of personnel on biosecurity and ASF, to avoid contacts with other pig herds, and to improve practices in the entrance into the farm. Sharing trucks with other farms, and loading/unloading of pigs were other weak points. Fencing was classified as insufficient in 70% of the commercial farms. Among these farms, breeding units were characterised by the lowest risk of ASFV introduction (although differences among median ranks were not statistically significant: P -value = 0.07; Kruskal–Wallis test), and increasing herd size was not significantly correlated with a higher risk (Kendall's τ = −0.13; P -value = 0.14). Density of farmed pig was greatest in the main pig production area in northern Italy. Conversely, exposure to wild boars was greatest for non-commercial/small commercial farms on the Apennines, which were also characterised by non-compliance with critical biosecurity measures.

• Publisher: Frontiers Media SA,Frontiers Media S.A
• Subject: African swine fever / Asfarviridae / Bats / Biosecurity / Check lists / Commercial farms / Data collection / Disease prevention / Entrances / failure mode and effect analysis / Failure modes / Farm buildings / Farms / Hogs / Personnel / pig / Population density / Pork / Risk assessment / Risk factors / Risk levels / semi-quantitative risk assessment / Statistical analysis / Swine / Swine production / Trade restrictions / Trucks / Veterinary Science