Journal Article

Participatory Indicator Development: What Can Ecologists and Local Communities Learn from Each Other

Baker, Timothy R., Dougill, Andrew J., Reed, Mark S.

2008

Overview

Given the growing popularity of indicators among policy-makers to measure progress toward conservation and sustainability goals, there is an urgent need to develop indicators that can be used accurately by both specialists and nonspecialists, drawing from the knowledge possessed by each group. This paper uses a case study from the Kalahari, Botswana to show how participatory and ecological methods can be combined to develop robust indicators that are accessible to a range of users to monitor and enhance the sustainability of land management. First, potential environmental sustainability indicators were elicited from pastoralists in three study sites. This knowledge was then evaluated by pastoralists, before being tested empirically using ecological and soil-based techniques. Despite the wealth of local knowledge about indicators, this knowledge was thinly spread. The knowledge was more holistic than published indicator lists for monitoring rangelands, encompassing vegetation, soil, livestock, wild animal, and socioeconomic indicators. Pastoralist preferences for vegetation and livestock indicators match recent shifts in ecological theory suggesting that livestock populations reach equilibrium with key forage resources in semiarid environments. Although most indicators suggested by pastoralists were validated through empirical work (e.g., decreased grass cover and soil organic matter content, and increased abundance of Acacia mellifera and thatching grass), they were not always sufficiently accurate or reliable for objective degradation assessment, showing that local knowledge cannot be accepted unquestioningly. We suggest that, by combining participatory and ecological approaches, it is possible to derive more accurate and relevant indicators than either approach could achieve alone.

• Publisher: Ecological Society of America
• Subject: Acacia / Acacia mellifera / Botswana / case studies / citizen participation / Conservation of Natural Resources / degradation / Ecological sustainability / ecologists / Ecology / Empirical Research / environmental indicators / Grasses / habitat conservation / human settlements / Hyparrhenia hirta / indigenous knowledge / Kalahari / Kalahari Desert / land / Land degradation / land management / Livestock / local knowledge / methodology / participation / Pastoralism / Rangeland soils / Senegalia mellifera / soil organic matter / southern Africa / sustainability indicators / Sustainable agriculture / Sustainable land management / Vegetation