Journal Article

A dimensional measure of safety behavior: A non-dichotomous assessment of costly avoidance in human fear conditioning

Pittig, Andre, Wong, Alex H. K.

2022

Overview

Safety behavior prevents the occurrence of threat, thus it is typically considered adaptive. However, safety behavior in anxiety-related disorders is often costly, and persists even the situation does not entail realistic threat. Individuals can engage in safety behavior to varying extents, however, these behaviors are typically measured dichotomously (i.e., to execute or not). To better understand the nuances of safety behavior, this study developed a dimensional measure of safety behavior that had a negative linear relationship with the admission of an aversive outcome. In two experiments, a Reward group receiving fixed or individually calibrated incentives competing with safety behavior showed reduced safety behavior than a Control group receiving no incentives. This allowed extinction learning to a previously learnt warning signal in the Reward group (i.e., updating the belief that this stimulus no longer signals threat). Despite the Reward group exhibited extinction learning, both groups showed a similar increase in fear to the warning signal once safety behavior was no longer available. This null group difference was due to some participants in the Reward group not incentivized enough to disengage from safety behavior. Dimensional assessment revealed a dissociation between low fear but substantial safety behavior to a safety signal in the Control group. This suggests that low-cost safety behavior does not accurately reflect the fear-driven processes, but also other non-fear-driven processes, such as cost (i.e., engage in safety behavior merely because it bears little to no cost). Pinpointing both processes is important for furthering the understanding of safety behavior.

• Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg,Springer Nature B.V
• Subject: Anxiety Disorders / Avoidance behavior / Avoidance Learning / Behavior / Behavioral Science and Psychology / Extinction behavior / Extinction, Psychological / Fear / Fear conditioning / Humans / Laboratories / Learning / Motivation / Original / Original Article / Psychology / Psychology Research / Reinforcement / Safety / Social anxiety / Threats