Journal Article

Interventions Designed to Improve Narrative Language in School-Age Children: A Systematic Review With Meta-Analyses

Woods, Christine, Contesse, Valentina A., Biel, Christa Haring, Biel, Eric J., Hessling Prahl, Alison, Peterson, Amy K., Pico, Danielle L.

2021

Overview

Purpose The purpose of this systematic review with meta-analyses was to examine interventions that aimed to improve narrative language outcomes for preschool and elementary school-age children in the United States. Our goal was to examine peer-reviewed publications to describe the characteristics of these interventions and synthesize their overall effectiveness on narrative comprehension and production via meta-analysis. Method We searched electronic databases, examined previously published reviews, and consulted experts in the field to identify published studies that employed robust experimental and quasi-experimental designs. We included randomized controlled trials, studies with nonrandomized comparison groups, and single-case design (SCD) studies. We completed a qualitative synthesis of study factors for all identified studies and calculated meta-analyses for the studies that had sufficient data. All included studies were analyzed for risk of bias. Results Our systematic search yielded 40 studies that included one or more narrative language outcomes as part of their assessment battery. Twenty-four of the included studies were group design studies, including randomized controlled trials and quasi-experimental designs, and the other 16 were SCD studies. Effect sizes were analyzed based on narrative production and comprehension outcomes. The meta-analyses of 26 studies indicated overall positive effects of the interventions, with effect sizes of = 0.51 and 0.54 in the group design studies and = 1.24 in the SCD studies. Conclusions A variety of effective interventions were found that improve narrative production and comprehension outcomes in children with diverse learner characteristics. Some common characteristics across these interventions include manualized curricula, opportunities to produce narrative language, verbal and visual supports, direct instruction of story grammar, and use of authentic children's literature. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.15079173.

• Publisher: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association
• Subject: Analysis / Audiences / Authentic texts / Care and treatment / Child / Child, Preschool / Children / Children & youth / Childrens literature / Clinical trials / Cognition & reasoning / Cognitive ability / Comprehension / Cultural differences / Curricula / Design / Direct instruction / Educational Research / Elementary education / Elementary School Students / Elementary schools / Grammar / Humans / Instructional Effectiveness / Intervention / Language / Language disorders / Language disorders in children / Language Skills / Linguistics / Literacy / Mathematics Achievement / Medical research / Meta-analysis / Narration / Narratives / Oral communication / Oral Language / Pediatric research / Peers / Preschool Children / Production / Psychological aspects / Quasi-experimental methods / Reading comprehension / Story grammar / Story Telling / Students / Systematic review / Teaching / Thinking Skills