Journal Article

Ethnic disparities in the use of restrictive practices in adult mental health inpatient settings: a scoping review

Damsgaard, Janne Brammer, Gildberg, Frederik, Pedersen, Martin Locht, Baker, John, Tingleff, Ellen Boldrup

2023

Overview

Purpose To identify and summarise extant knowledge about patient ethnicity and the use of various types of restrictive practices in adult mental health inpatient settings. Methods A scoping review methodological framework recommended by the JBI was used. A systematic search was conducted in APA PsycINFO, CINAHL with Full Text, Embase, PubMed and Scopus. Additionally, grey literature searches were conducted in Google, OpenGrey and selected websites, and the reference lists of included studies were explored. Results Altogether, 38 studies were included: 34 were primary studies; 4, reviews. The geographical settings were as follows: Europe ( n  = 26), Western Pacific ( n  = 8), Americas ( n  = 3) and South-East Asia ( n  = 1). In primary studies, ethnicity was reported according to migrant/national status ( n  = 16), mixed categories ( n  = 12), indigenous vs. non-indigenous ( n  = 5), region of origin ( n  = 1), sub-categories of indigenous people ( n  = 1) and religion ( n  = 1). In reviews, ethnicity was not comparable. The categories of restrictive practices included seclusion, which was widely reported across the studies ( n  = 20), multiple restrictive practices studied concurrently ( n  = 17), mechanical restraint ( n  = 8), rapid tranquillisation ( n  = 7) and manual restraint ( n  = 1). Conclusions Ethnic disparities in restrictive practice use in adult mental health inpatient settings has received some scholarly attention. Evidence suggests that certain ethnic minorities were more likely to experience restrictive practices than other groups. However, extant research was characterised by a lack of consensus and continuity. Furthermore, widely different definitions of ethnicity and restrictive practices were used, which hampers researchers’ and clinicians’ understanding of the issue. Further research in this field may improve mental health practice.

• Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg,Springer,Springer Nature B.V
• Subject: Adult / Categories / Constraints / Cultural differences / Epidemiology / Ethnicity / Europe / Humans / Indigenous peoples / Inpatients / Literature reviews / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Mental Health / Minority & ethnic groups / Psychiatry / Restraint, Physical / Review / Search engines / Websites