Journal Article

Strong intercorrelations among global graph-theoretic indices of structural connectivity in the human brain

Rhemtulla, Mijke, Bastin, Mark E., Ritchie, Stuart J., Buchanan, Colin R., Deary, Ian J., Cox, Simon R., Madole, James W., Tucker-Drob, Elliot M.

2023

Overview

•Global network metrics are used to measure organizational properties of the brain.•Many metrics are highly correlated with each other and with topology-free metrics.•Network sparsity and variation in edge weights may yield greater independence between metrics. Graph-theoretic metrics derived from neuroimaging data have been heralded as powerful tools for uncovering neural mechanisms of psychological traits, psychiatric disorders, and neurodegenerative diseases. In N = 8,185 human structural connectomes from UK Biobank, we examined the extent to which 11 commonly-used global graph-theoretic metrics index distinct versus overlapping information with respect to interindividual differences in brain organization. Using unthresholded, FA-weighted networks we found that all metrics other than Participation Coefficient were highly intercorrelated, both with each other (mean |r| = 0.788) and with a topologically-naïve summary index of brain structure (mean edge weight; mean |r| = 0.873). In a series of sensitivity analyses, we found that overlap between metrics is influenced by the sparseness of the network and the magnitude of variation in edge weights. Simulation analyses representing a range of population network structures indicated that individual differences in global graph metrics may be intrinsically difficult to separate from mean edge weight. In particular, Closeness, Characteristic Path Length, Global Efficiency, Clustering Coefficient, and Small Worldness were nearly perfectly collinear with one another (mean |r| = 0.939) and with mean edge weight (mean |r| = 0.952) across all observed and simulated conditions. Global graph-theoretic measures are valuable for their ability to distill a high-dimensional system of neural connections into summary indices of brain organization, but they may be of more limited utility when the goal is to index separable components of interindividual variation in specific properties of the human structural connectome.

• Publisher: Elsevier Inc,Elsevier Limited,Elsevier
• Subject: Automation / Biobanks / Brain / Brain - diagnostic imaging / Brain architecture / Connectome - methods / Connectomics / diffusion MRI / Graph theory / Humans / Magnetic Resonance Imaging - methods / Mental Disorders / Network neuroscience / Neural networks / Neurodegenerative diseases / Neuroimaging / Neurosciences / Phenotype / Sensitivity analysis / Structural MRI / Weight