Journal Article

Comparative speed of kill provided by lotilaner (Credelio™), sarolaner (Simparica Trio™), and afoxolaner (NexGard™) to control Amblyomma americanum infestations on dogs

Bell, Marjorie C., Dryden, Michael W., Jesudoss Chelladurai, Jeba R. J., Miller, Kamilyah R., Ryan, William G., Sutherland, Cameron J., Beltz, Mallory S., Reif, Kathryn E., Kollasch, Todd M., Herrin, Brian H., Neilson, Jacqueline C.

2024

Overview

Abstract Background Canine acaricides with rapid onset and sustained activity can reduce pathogen transmission risk and enhance pet owner experience. This randomized, complete block design, investigator-masked study compared the speed of kill of Amblyomma americanum provided by three monthly-use isoxazoline-containing products. Methods Eight randomized beagles per group were treated (day 0), per label, with sarolaner (combined with moxidectin and pyrantel, Simparica Trio™), afoxolaner (NexGard™), or lotilaner (Credelio™), or remained untreated. Infestations with 50 adult A. americanum were conducted on days − 7, − 2, 21, and 28, and tick counts were performed on day − 5 (for blocking), and at 4, 8, 12, 24, 48, and 72 h following treatment and subsequent infestations. Efficacy calculations were based on geometric mean live tick counts. A linear mixed model was used for between-group comparisons. Results On day 0, only lotilaner significantly reduced an A. americanum infestation by 12 h (43.3%; P  = 0.002). Efficacy of lotilaner and afoxolaner at 24 h post-treatment was 95.3% and 97.6%, respectively, both significantly different from sarolaner (74%) ( P  = 0.002, P  < 0.001, respectively). On day 21, at 12 h postinfestation, lotilaner efficacy (59.6%) was significantly different from sarolaner (0.0%) ( P  < 0.001) and afoxolaner (6.3%) ( P  < 0.001). At 24 h, lotilaner efficacy (97.4%) was significantly different ( P  < 0.001) from sarolaner and afoxolaner (13.6% and 14.9%, respectively). On day 28, at 12 h postinfestation, lotilaner efficacy (47.8%) was significantly different from sarolaner (17.1%) ( P  = 0.020) and afoxolaner (9.0%) ( P  = 0.006). At 24 h, lotilaner efficacy (92.3%) was significantly different from sarolaner 4.9% ( P  < 0.001) and afoxolaner (0.0%) ( P  < 0.001). Speed of kill for sarolaner and afoxolaner, but not lotilaner, significantly declined over the study period. Following reinfestation on day 28, neither sarolaner nor afoxolaner reached 90% efficacy by 48 h. By 72 h, sarolaner efficacy was 97.4% and afoxolaner efficacy was 86.3%. Only lotilaner achieved ≥ 90% efficacy by 24 h post-treatment and 24 h postinfestation on days 21 and 28. Time to ≥ 90% efficacy following new infestations consistently occurred 24–48 h earlier for lotilaner compared with sarolaner or afoxolaner. Conclusions Credelio (lotilaner) has a more rapid onset of acaricidal activity against A. americanum than Simparica Trio (sarolaner-moxidectin-pyrantel) and NexGard (afoxolaner). Only lotilaner’s speed of tick kill is sustained throughout the dosing period. Graphical Abstract

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BMC
• Subject: 17th and 18th Symposium on Companion Vector-Borne Diseases (CVBD) / acaricidal properties / acaricides / Acaricides - administration & dosage / adults / Afoxolaner / Amblyomma - drug effects / Amblyomma americanum / Animals / antiparasitic agents / Azetidines - administration & dosage / Azetidines - therapeutic use / Biomedical and Life Sciences / Biomedicine / Canine / Credelio / disease transmission / Dog / Dog Diseases - drug therapy / Dog Diseases - parasitology / Dogs / Entomology / Female / Infectious Diseases / Isoxazoles - administration & dosage / Isoxazoles - therapeutic use / Lone star tick / Male / Naphthalenes - administration & dosage / Naphthalenes - therapeutic use / Oxazoles / Parasitology / pet ownership / risk / Spiro Compounds - administration & dosage / Spiro Compounds - therapeutic use / statistical models / Thiophenes / Tick Infestations - drug therapy / Tick Infestations - prevention & control / Tick Infestations - veterinary / ticks / Time Factors / Treatment Outcome / Tropical Medicine / Veterinary Medicine/Veterinary Science / Virology