Journal Article

Comparison of functional assays used in the clinical development of a placental malaria vaccine

Nielsen, Morten A., Pehrson, Caroline, Resende, Mafalda, Mathiesen, Line, de Jongh, Willem A., Adams, Yvonne, Heno, Kristine K., Salanti, Ali, Soegaard, Max, Theander, Thor G.

2017

Overview

•Comparability of placental malaria vaccine potency assays was investigated.•Results from different binding inhibition assays cannot be compared directly.•Sera should be tested in a dilution series.•The level of parasite binding avidity affects the antibody inhibition. Malaria in pregnancy is associated with significant morbidity in pregnant women and their offspring. Plasmodium falciparum infected erythrocytes (IE) express VAR2CSA that mediates binding to chondroitin sulphate A (CSA) in the placenta. Two VAR2CSA-based vaccines for placental malaria are in clinical development. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the robustness and comparability of binding inhibition assays used in the clinical development of placental malaria vaccines. The ability of sera from animals immunised with different VAR2CSA constructs to inhibit IE binding to CSA was investigated in three in vitro assays using 96-well plates, petri dishes, capillary flow and an ex vivo placental perfusion assay. The inter-assay variation was not uniform between assays and ranged from above ten-fold in the flow assay to two-fold in the perfusion assay. The intra-assay variation was highest in the petri dish assay. A positive correlation between IE binding avidity and the level of binding after antibody inhibition in the petri dish assay indicate that high avidity IE binding is more difficult to inhibit. The highest binding inhibition sensitivity was found in the 96-well and petri dish assays compared to the flow and perfusion assays where binding inhibition required higher antibody titers. The inhibitory capacity of antibodies is not easily translated between assays and the high sensitivity of the 96-well and petri dish assays stresses the need for comparing serial dilutions of serum. Furthermore, IE binding avidity must be in the same range when comparing data from different days. There was an overall concordance in the capacity of antibody-mediated inhibition, when comparing the in vitro assays with the perfusion assay, which more closely represents in vivo conditions. Importantly the ID1-ID2a protein in a liposomal formulation, currently in a phase I trial, effectively induced antibodies that inhibited IE adhesion in placental tissue.

• Publisher: Elsevier Ltd,Elsevier Limited
• Subject: Allergy and Immunology / animal tissues / Animals / antibodies / Antibodies, Protozoan - blood / Antigens, Protozoan - immunology / Binding inhibition assay / blood serum / Cell Adhesion / chondroitin sulfate / Chondroitin Sulfates - metabolism / Clinical trials / Cytological Techniques - methods / Drug Discovery - methods / erythrocytes / Erythrocytes - parasitology / Erythrocytes - physiology / Experiments / Female / Immunization / Immunoglobulins / in vitro studies / Infectious diseases / Malaria / malaria vaccines / Malaria Vaccines - administration & dosage / Malaria Vaccines - immunology / Malaria, Falciparum - prevention & control / Mice, Inbred C57BL / morbidity / Offspring / Parasites / placenta / Placenta Diseases - prevention & control / Placental malaria / Plasmodium falciparum / Pregnancy / pregnant women / progeny / Proteins / Rabbits / Rats, Wistar / Reproducibility of Results / Standard deviation / Vaccine development / Vaccines / VAR2CSA / Vector-borne diseases