Journal Article

Mentorship needs and satisfaction of MD-PhD and MD-MSc trainees with marginalized identities: the Canadian experience

Lao, Robert X., Bogie, Bryce J. M., Misaghi, Ehsan, Yin, Charles, Al-Azzawi, Zaid A. M., Luigi, Mimosa

2025

Overview

Physician-scientists (PS) are the backbone of translational research and groundbreaking medical developments in many developed countries. Formalized PS training programs in the form of MD-PhD/MD-MSc programs in Canada have had a longstanding tradition of producing many exceptional PS researchers, staff, and faculty. However, despite these programs’ growth in size and popularity, PS trainees have consistently reported high rates of burnout, attrition, and lack of adequate mentorship and financial support. Additionally, there has been no formalized research examining the needs and prevalence of PS trainees who identify as having a marginalized identity, who may present different unaddressed needs. For the first time, this work captures the demographics, satisfaction, and needs of Canadian MD-PhD/MD-MSc trainees at the intersection of multiple marginalized identities. The authors utilized data from a cross-sectional survey conducted between June to December 2021 by the Clinician Investigator Trainee Association of Canada. Authors examined five marginalized identities covered by the survey: identifying as a woman, living with a disability, a visible minority, not being born in Canada, and being a primary caregiver during training. Results show that 78% of PS trainees self-identify with a marginalized identity and 47% with at least two identities, a proportion higher than previously published. In addition, specific marginalized identity groups reported differing needs as top priority. Moreover, PS trainees who identified with having a disability and who were primary caregivers during training reported significant dissatisfaction within their training programs. In addition to unique needs for each identity group, certain needs were expressed by all marginalized identity groups such as lack of adequate and specific mentorship during training. This research contributes novel data by examining an underrepresented group of PS trainees and supports previous calls to action within the literature expressing the need for greater oversight and infrastructure to support PS training in Canada.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Addition / Adult / Alumni / Canada / Career development planning / Career Planning / Careers / Caregivers / Cross-Sectional Studies / Curricula / Data Analysis / Doctoral Students / Education / Education, Medical, Graduate / Educational research / Family Income / Female / Funding / Humans / Identity / Likert scale / Likert Scales / Male / Marginalized / MD-PhD / Medical colleges / Medical Education / Medicine / Mentors / Mentors - psychology / Minorities in medicine / MSc / National Surveys / Outcome Measures / Personal Satisfaction / Physicians / Polls & surveys / Professional Identity / Psychological aspects / Response rates / Response Rates (Questionnaires) / Satisfaction / Scientists / Self esteem / Social Marginalization - psychology / Student Satisfaction / Students / Surveys and Questionnaires / Theory of Medicine/Bioethics / Trainees / Training / Variables