Journal Article

A Participant-Level Integrative Data Analysis of Differential Placebo Response for Suicidal Ideation and Nonsuicidal Depressive Symptoms in Clinical Trials of Intravenous Racemic Ketamine

Carlos A Zarate, Bartholt Bloomfield-Clagett, Jennifer L Phillips, Deanna K Greenstein, Elizabeth D Ballard, Sanjay J Mathew, Samuel T Wilkinson, Gerard Sanacora, Maurizio Fava, Michael F Grunebaum, James W Murrough

2022

Overview

Abstract Background Clinical trials of intravenous (IV) racemic (R,S)-ketamine (hereafter referred to as IV ketamine) have consistently reported rapid and substantial reductions in overall depressive symptoms compared with saline (inactive placebo) or midazolam (active placebo). The evidence for IV ketamine’s specific effects on suicidal ideation is less clear, however. This study sought to examine whether differential placebo (saline or midazolam) response to overall depressive symptoms vs suicidal ideation may help explain these divergent findings. Methods Data for this participant-level integrative data analysis were drawn from 151 participants across 10 studies, and linear regression was used to examine the relationship between placebo response for suicidal ideation vs other depressive symptoms indexed from standard rating scales—specifically, depressed mood, anhedonia, anxiety, and guilt—over time. Results For participants receiving saline placebo (n = 46), greater placebo response was observed for suicidal ideation compared with other symptoms indexed from standard depression rating scales, except for anxiety. For those receiving midazolam placebo (n = 105), greater placebo response was observed for suicidal ideation compared with depressed mood or anhedonia, and no significant differences were observed when comparing suicidal ideation with anxiety or guilt. Conclusions Taken together, the results provide preliminary evidence of a differential placebo response for suicidal ideation vs other depressive symptoms, while anxiety and suicidal ideation appear to produce similar placebo response profiles. These findings may help explain the more modest findings in clinical IV ketamine trials for suicidal ideation than overall depression.

• Publisher: Oxford University Press (OUP),Oxford University Press
• Subject: Anhedonia / Anxiety / Clinical trials / Data Analysis / Depression / Depression - drug therapy / Depression, Mental / Depressive Disorder, Major / Depressive Disorder, Major - drug therapy / Dosage and administration / Humans / Intravenous therapy / Ketamine / Ketamine - therapeutic use / Midazolam / Midazolam - therapeutic use / Placebo Effect / Psychiatric Status Rating Scales / Regular s / Risk factors / Suicidal behavior / Suicidal Ideation / Testing