Journal Article

Interpersonal symptoms in adolescence depression across Asian and European regions: a network approach

Cheung, H. N., Asgarabad, M. Habibi, Ho, W. S., Zibetti, M. R., Williams, J. M., Li, S. T. K., Stella, W. Y. Chan

2024

Overview

Background Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) poses a significant global health challenge, with symptom presentation potentially varying between adolescents and adults. Adolescence is a critical period marked by heightened vulnerability to interpersonal stresses, yet the impact of these stresses on the structure of depressive symptoms is not well understood. Recognizing the cultural nuances in how depression manifests among adolescents is crucial. To this end, this paper employs a network analysis approach, utilizing a comprehensive symptom checklist from the Multidimensional Depression Assessment Scale (MDAS). Our study investigates the role of interpersonal symptoms within the broader cluster of emotional, cognitive, and somatic symptoms and explores variations in adolescent groups in four Asian and European regions. Methods We recruited a diverse sample of 6,348 adolescents aged 12 to 18 from Hong Kong, Taiwan, the UK, China, and the Netherlands using the Qualtrics platform. Employing the Gaussian Graphical Model, we established a network model of depressive symptoms as measured by the MDAS, segregating the sample into Asian and European regions to examine the interconnections between them. The study focused on identifying central symptom nodes and comparing the network structures between the two groups. Results The analysis identified feeling worthless , low energy , being a burden to others , and low mood as central symptoms of depression. Notably, there were significant differences in the connections between depressive symptoms among Asian (Hong Kong, China and Taiwan) and European (UK and the Netherlands) adolescents, highlighting cultural variations in how interpersonal symptoms interact with emotional, cognitive, and somatic symptoms. Conclusion This study is pioneering in applying network analysis to include interpersonal symptoms in examining depression among a diverse adolescent population. It demonstrates that interpersonal symptoms are integral to the central features of depressive symptoms. Furthermore, our findings suggest that, compared to their UK and Dutch peers, interpersonal symptoms in Asian adolescents are uniquely connected to other symptom clusters, reflecting distinct cultural patterns. Limitations: The study engaged a broad community sample; however, future research could benefit from including a larger sample size to allow for a more detailed analysis of a greater number of symptom nodes.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adolescence / Adolescent / Adolescents / Asian People - psychology / Child / Child & adolescent mental health / Child development / China - ethnology / Critical period / Cross-Cultural Comparison / Cultural differences / Depression / Depression - ethnology / Depression - psychology / Depression in adolescence / Depressive Disorder, Major - ethnology / Depressive Disorder, Major - psychology / Emotions / Ethnicity / Europe - ethnology / Female / Health aspects / Hong Kong / Humans / Interpersonal Relations / Interpersonal Symptoms / Male / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Mental depression / Mental disorders / Minority & ethnic groups / Netherlands - ethnology / Network model / Population studies / Psychiatric Status Rating Scales / Psychiatry / Psychological aspects / Psychotherapy / Public health / Self report / Social aspects / Social isolation / Taiwan - ethnology / Teenagers / United Kingdom - ethnology