Journal Article

Trust in Forecast Information Sharing

Özer, Özalp, Chen, Kay-Yut, Zheng, Yanchong

2011

Overview

This paper investigates the capacity investment decision of a supplier who solicits private forecast information from a manufacturer. To ensure abundant supply, the manufacturer has an incentive to inflate her forecast in a costless, nonbinding, and nonverifiable type of communication known as \"cheap talk.\" According to standard game theory, parties do not cooperate and the only equilibrium is uninformative-the manufacturer's report is independent of her forecast and the supplier does not use the report to determine capacity. However, we observe in controlled laboratory experiments that parties cooperate even in the absence of reputation-building mechanisms and complex contracts. We argue that the underlying reason for cooperation is trust and trustworthiness. The extant literature on forecast sharing and supply chain coordination implicitly assumes that supply chain members either absolutely trust each other and cooperate when sharing forecast information, or do not trust each other at all. Contrary to this all-or-nothing view, we determine that a continuum exists between these two extremes. In addition, we determine (i) when trust is important in forecast information sharing, (ii) how trust is affected by changes in the supply chain environment, and (iii) how trust affects related operational decisions. To explain and better understand the observed behavioral regularities, we also develop an analytical model of trust to incorporate both pecuniary and nonpecuniary incentives in the game-theoretic analysis of cheap-talk forecast communication. The model identifies and quantifies how trust and trustworthiness induce effective cheap-talk forecast sharing under the wholesale price contract. We also determine the impact of repeated interactions and information feedback on trust and cooperation in forecast sharing. We conclude with a discussion on the implications of our results for developing effective forecast management policies. This paper was accepted by Ananth Iyer, operations and supply chain management.

• Publisher: INFORMS,Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences
• Subject: Applied sciences / asymmetric forecast information / Behavioral decision theory / behavioral economics / Capacity costs / Cheap talk / Cooperation / Credibility / Decision theory. Utility theory / Exact sciences and technology / experimental economics / Experiments / Financial information / Forecasting / Forecasting models / Forecasting standards / Forecasts / Forecasts and trends / Game theory / Information dissemination / Information sharing / Informationsverbreitung / Investment decision / Lieferkette / Logistics / Management science / Manufacturing / Modeling / Operational research and scientific management / Operational research. Management science / Operations Research / Portfolio theory / Prognoseverfahren / Sharing / Statistical forecasts / Studies / Suppliers / Supply / Supply chain management / Trust / trustworthiness / U.S.A / Verhaltensökonomik / Vertrauen / wholesale price contract / Wholesale prices