Journal Article

The accuracy of computed tomography scans for rapid prototyping of canine skulls

Phillips, John, Oblak, Michelle, Zur Linden, Alex, James, Fiona M. K., Monteith, Gabrielle, Comrie, Michaela L.

2019

Overview

This study's objective was to determine the accuracy of using current computed tomography (CT) scan and software techniques for rapid prototyping by quantifying the margin of error between CT models and laser scans of canine skull specimens. Twenty canine skulls of varying morphology were selected from an anatomy collection at a veterinary school. CT scans (bone and standard algorithms) were performed for each skull, and data segmented (testing two lower threshold settings of 226HU and -650HU) into 3-D CT models. Laser scans were then performed on each skull. The CT models were compared to the corresponding laser scan to determine the error generated from the different types of CT model parameters. This error was then compared between the different types of CT models to determine the most accurate parameters. The mean errors for the 226HU CT models, both bone and standard algorithms, were not significant from zero error (p = 0.1076 and p = 0.0580, respectively). The mean errors for both -650HU CT models were significant from zero error (p < 0.001). Significant differences were detected between CT models for 3 CT model comparisons: Bone (p < 0.0001); Standard (p < 0.0001); and -650HU (p < 0.0001). For 226HU CT models, a significant difference was not detected between CT models (p = 0.2268). Independent of the parameters tested, the 3-D models derived from CT imaging accurately represent the real skull dimensions, with CT models differing less than 0.42 mm from the real skull dimensions. The 226HU threshold was more accurate than the -650HU threshold. For the 226HU CT models, accuracy was not dependent on the CT algorithm. For the -650 CT models, bone was more accurate than standard algorithms. Knowing the inherent error of this procedure is important for use in 3-D printing for surgical planning and medical education.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: 3D printing / Algorithms / Analysis / Animals / Biology and Life Sciences / CAT scans / Comparative analysis / Computation / Computed tomography / Diagnostic imaging / Dogs / Education / Engineering and Technology / Error detection / Imaging, Three-Dimensional / Lasers / Mathematical models / Medical imaging / Medical imaging equipment / Medical personnel training / Medicine and Health Sciences / Model accuracy / Morphology / Parameters / Rapid prototyping / Research and Analysis Methods / Skull / Skull - diagnostic imaging / Surgery / Three dimensional models / Three dimensional printing / Tomography / Tomography, X-Ray Computed / Veterinary colleges