Journal Article

Simulation vs. Reality: A Comparison of In Silico Distance Predictions with DEER and FRET Measurements

Grohmann, Dina, Klose, Daniel, Klare, Johann P., Werner, Finn, Steinhoff, Heinz-Jürgen, Kay, Christopher W. M.

2012

Overview

Site specific incorporation of molecular probes such as fluorescent- and nitroxide spin-labels into biomolecules, and subsequent analysis by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) and double electron-electron resonance (DEER) can elucidate the distance and distance-changes between the probes. However, the probes have an intrinsic conformational flexibility due to the linker by which they are conjugated to the biomolecule. This property minimizes the influence of the label side chain on the structure of the target molecule, but complicates the direct correlation of the experimental inter-label distances with the macromolecular structure or changes thereof. Simulation methods that account for the conformational flexibility and orientation of the probe(s) can be helpful in overcoming this problem. We performed distance measurements using FRET and DEER and explored different simulation techniques to predict inter-label distances using the Rpo4/7 stalk module of the M. jannaschii RNA polymerase. This is a suitable model system because it is rigid and a high-resolution X-ray structure is available. The conformations of the fluorescent labels and nitroxide spin labels on Rpo4/7 were modeled using in vacuo molecular dynamics simulations (MD) and a stochastic Monte Carlo sampling approach. For the nitroxide probes we also performed MD simulations with explicit water and carried out a rotamer library analysis. Our results show that the Monte Carlo simulations are in better agreement with experiments than the MD simulations and the rotamer library approach results in plausible distance predictions. Because the latter is the least computationally demanding of the methods we have explored, and is readily available to many researchers, it prevails as the method of choice for the interpretation of DEER distance distributions.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Algorithms / Biological products / Biology / Biomolecules / Boundary conditions / Comparative analysis / Computer Science / Computer Simulation / Distance measurement / DNA probes / DNA-directed RNA polymerase / DNA-Directed RNA Polymerases / Electron Spin Resonance Spectroscopy - methods / Energy conservation / Energy transfer / Flexibility / Fluorescence / Fluorescence resonance energy transfer / Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer - methods / Fluorescent indicators / Labels / Laboratories / Libraries / Macromolecules / Mathematical models / Models, Molecular / Molecular biology / Molecular Conformation / Molecular dynamics / Molecular Dynamics Simulation / Molecular structure / Monte Carlo methods / Monte Carlo simulation / Nitroxide / Physics / Probes / Proteins / Quantum physics / Resonance / Ribonucleic acid / RNA / Simulation / Spin Labels / Stochasticity / Supercomputers