Journal Article

Contraceptive care for transgender and gender diverse individuals from the perspective of healthcare providers in Germany: a qualitative study

Herrmann, Lena, Pohontsch, Nadine Janis, Bindt, Carola, Becker-Hebly, Inga, Barton, Charlotte, Werner, Marie

2025

Overview

Background Gender-affirming hormones do not completely suppress fertility in transgender and gender diverse individuals, highlighting the need for counseling on pregnancy risk and contraceptive options. However, research on current contraceptive care is limited. Studies from the US have identified several barriers to care as well as facilitators, but no studies on this topic have yet been conducted in Europe. This study examined transgender and gender diverse contraceptive care in Germany from the perspective of healthcare providers, assessing its importance and their roles in it, as well as exploring barriers and facilitators. Methods Thirty semistructured qualitative interviews with German healthcare providers were conducted between December 2023 and February 2024. The interview guide included questions on contraceptive care for transgender and gender diverse individuals. Data were analyzed using structuring qualitative content analysis (Kuckartz) with deductive and inductive category development. Results Most interviewees highlighted the need for contraceptive care, depending on various factors such as the type of gender-affirming care applied, sexual practices, and transgender and gender diverse individuals’ desire for pregnancy prevention. Half of the interviewees also offered contraceptive care (depending on their specialization). Numerous barriers to contraceptive care, such as a lack of awareness of contraceptive needs, insufficient research and training programs for medical staff, have been reported, highlighting the importance of facilitators for care such as the implementation of contraceptive counseling as a standard protocol. Conclusion To improve contraceptive care for transgender and gender diverse individuals, the establishment of clear structures and responsibilities, more research, and qualifications among the involved specialties are needed. To gain a comprehensive understanding of the care situation, future research should include the perspectives of transgender and gender diverse individuals. Trial registration We obtained the approval of the Hamburg Medical Council (“Ärztekammer Hamburg”) to conduct our study by means of a “scientific case” (2023-300381-WF, September 11th 2023). Plain english summary Transgender and gender diverse people experience persistent incongruence between their experienced gender identity and their sex assigned at birth - diagnosed as gender incongruence. Many use gender-affirming hormones, such as testosterone or estrogen, to match gender identity and body. These hormones decrease the ability to get pregnant but do not stop it completely. That’s why it is important to give this population information about pregnancy risks and contraceptive options. So far, most research on this topic has come from the US, but little is known about the situation in Europe. This study looked at how healthcare providers in Germany think about contraceptive care for transgender and gender diverse people and how they experience care provision. Thirty healthcare providers (medical doctors and psychologists) in Germany were interviewed between December 2023 and February 2024. Most healthcare providers said they believed contraceptive care was important for transgender and gender diverse people, depending on factors like the type of hormones used and sexual practices, and half of the healthcare providers also offered contraceptive care. Some common challenges included a lack of knowledge about contraception for transgender and gender diverse people, lack of research, and limited training of medical staff. Healthcare providers said that better contraceptive care for transgender and gender-diverse people in Germany needs more research, clear protocols or guidelines, as well as more training for healthcare providers. Future studies should also ask transgender and gender diverse people themselves about their needs and experiences.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,BMC
• Subject: Adult / Analysis / Attitude of Health Personnel / Barriers to care / Contraception / Contraception - methods / Contraceptives / Counseling / Family Planning Services / Female / Gender Equity in Reproductive Health Service Access / Germany / Health aspects / Health Personnel - psychology / Healthcare / Humans / Male / Maternal and Child Health / Medical personnel / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Middle Aged / Practice / Pregnancy / Public Health / Qualitative Research / Reproductive health / Reproductive Medicine / Social aspects / Transgender people / Transgender Persons - psychology