Journal Article

Competencies for proficiency in basic point-of-care ultrasound in anesthesiology: national expert recommendations using Delphi methodology

Shatenko, Sergiy, Ho, Anthony M.-H., Mizubuti, Glenio B., Maxwell, Sarah, Arellano, Ramiro, Braund, Heather, Hobbs, Hailey, Szulewski, Adam, Haji, Faizal, Dalgarno, Nancy, Phelan, Rachel

2024

Overview

Purpose Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) allows for rapid bedside assessment and guidance of patient care. Recently, POCUS was included as a mandatory component of Canadian anesthesiology training; however, there is no national consensus regarding the competencies to guide curriculum development. We therefore aimed to define national residency competencies for basic perioperative POCUS proficiency. Methods We adopted a Delphi process to delineate relevant POCUS competencies whereby we circulated an online survey to academic anesthesiologists identified as POCUS leads/experts ( n  = 25) at all 17 Canadian anesthesiology residency programs. After reviewing a list of competencies derived from the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada’s National Curriculum, we asked participants to accept, refine, delete, or add competencies. Three rounds were completed between 2022 and 2023. We discarded items with < 50% agreement, revised those with 50–79% agreement based upon feedback provided, and maintained unrevised those items with ≥ 80% agreement. Results We initially identified and circulated (Round 1) 74 competencies across 19 clinical domains (e.g., basics of ultrasound [equipment, nomenclature, clinical governance, physics]; cardiac [left ventricle, right ventricle, valve assessment, pericardial effusion, intravascular volume status] and lung ultrasound anatomy, image acquisition, and image interpretation; and clinical applications [monitoring and serial assessments, persistent hypotension, respiratory distress, cardiac arrest]). After three Delphi rounds (and 100% response rate maintained), panellists ultimately agreed upon 75 competencies. Conclusion Through national expert consensus, this study identified POCUS competencies suitable for curriculum development and assessment in perioperative anesthesiology. Next steps include designing and piloting a POCUS curriculum and assessment tool(s) based upon these nationally defined competencies.

• Publisher: Springer International Publishing
• Subject: Anesthesiology / Cardiology / Critical Care Medicine / Intensive / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Pain Medicine / Pediatrics / Pneumology/Respiratory System / Reports of Original Investigations