Journal Article

Complex Trait Prediction from Genome Data: Contrasting EBV in Livestock to PRS in Humans

Kemper, Kathryn E, Visscher, Peter M, Hayes, Benjamin J, Goddard, Michael E, Wray, Naomi R

2019

Overview

Genomic estimated breeding values (GEBVs) in livestock and polygenic risk scores (PRS) in humans are conceptually similar; however, the between-species differences in linkage disequilibrium (LD) provide a fundamental point of distinction that impacts approaches to data analyses... In this Review, we focus on the similarity of the concepts underlying prediction of estimated breeding values (EBVs) in livestock and polygenic risk scores (PRS) in humans. Our research spans both fields and so we recognize factors that are very obvious for those in one field, but less so for those in the other. Differences in family size between species is the wedge that drives the different viewpoints and approaches. Large family size achievable in nonhuman species accompanied by selection generates a smaller effective population size, increased linkage disequilibrium and a higher average genetic relationship between individuals within a population. In human genetic analyses, we select individuals unrelated in the classical sense (coefficient of relationship <0.05) to estimate heritability captured by common SNPs. In livestock data, all animals within a breed are to some extent “related,” and so it is not possible to select unrelated individuals and retain a data set of sufficient size to analyze. These differences directly or indirectly impact the way data analyses are undertaken. In livestock, genetic segregation variance exposed through samplings of parental genomes within families is directly observable and taken for granted. In humans, this genomic variation is under-recognized for its contribution to variation in polygenic risk of common disease, in both those with and without family history of disease. We explore the equation that predicts the expected proportion of variance explained using PRS, and quantify how GWAS sample size is the key factor for maximizing accuracy of prediction in both humans and livestock. Last, we bring together the concepts discussed to address some frequently asked questions.

• Publisher: Genetics Society of America
• Subject: Accuracy / Animal husbandry / Data processing / Deoxyribonucleic acid / Disease / DNA / Family size / Genetic analysis / Genetic engineering / Genetic relationship / Genetics / Genomes / Genotype & phenotype / Heritability / Impact analysis / Linkage disequilibrium / Livestock / Livestock breeding / Polygenic inheritance / Population genetics / Population number / Single-nucleotide polymorphism