Journal Article

Impacts of conservation agriculture on crop yield and soil carbon sequestration: a meta-analysis in the Indian subcontinent

Kumar, Upendra, Sinha, Abhas Kumar, Rana, D. S., Bhattacharya, Prateek M., Kaviraj, Megha, Kumar, Rajkishore, Padbhushan, Rajeev, Datta, Ashim, Mondal, Surajit, Bijay-Singh, Mitra, Biplab

2024

Overview

In the quest of achieving sustainable crop productivity, improved soil health, and increased carbon (C) sequestration in the soil, conservation agriculture (CA) is increasingly being promoted and adopted in the Indian subcontinent. However, because some researchers from different regions of the world have reported reduced crop yield under CA relative to agriculture based on conventional tillage (CT), a meta-analysis has been conducted based on published research from India to evaluate the effects of CA on the yield of crops, accumulation of soil organic C as an index of soil health, and C sequestration in the soil in different regions and soil textural groups in the country. The meta-analysis is based on 544 paired observations under CA and CT from 35 publications from India was carried out using Meta Win 2.1 software. The results showed an overall significant ( p  < 0.05) reduction of 1.15% crop yield under CA compared to CT. Yearwise data showed a reduction of yields under CA from 2009 to 2016, but an increase from 2017 to 2020. Yield reduction was observed in the eastern, north-eastern, and southern regions of India but in western, northern, and north-western regions of the country, an increase was observed under CA rather than CT. Sandy loam and clayey soils exhibited higher crop yield under CA than under CT. Compared to CT, soil organic C content and soil C sequestration under CA increased by 8.9% and 7.3%, respectively. Also, in all the regions and soil textural groups both soil organic C accumulation and soil C sequestration were higher under CA than under CT. Factors such as rainfall, soil depth, available nitrogen (N), and total N significantly influenced the extent of yield increase/decrease and soil organic C accumulation under CA. Overall, results of the meta-analysis suggest that the promotion of CA in India will have to be location-specific taking into consideration the crops, soil attributes, and climatic conditions. Graphical abstract

• Publisher: Springer Netherlands,Springer Nature B.V
• Subject: Accumulation / Agricultural conservation / agricultural conservation practice / Agricultural production / Agriculture / Agriculture - methods / Carbon / Carbon - analysis / Carbon Sequestration / Clay / Clay soils / Climatic conditions / computer software / Conservation / Conservation of Natural Resources / conventional tillage / Crop production / Crop yield / Crops / Crops, Agricultural / Earth and Environmental Science / Environment / Environmental Chemistry / Environmental Health / Geochemistry / India / Meta-analysis / Nitrogen / Original Paper / Public Health / rain / Rainfall / Regions / Sandy loam / sandy loam soils / Sandy soils / Soil / Soil - chemistry / Soil conservation / Soil depth / Soil improvement / soil organic carbon / soil quality / Soil Science & Conservation / Sustainable agriculture / Terrestrial Pollution / total nitrogen