Journal Article

Breeding system of diploid sexuals within the Ranunculus auricomus complex and its role in a geographical parthenogenesis scenario

Tomasello, Salvatore, Hörandl, Elvira, Hodač, Ladislav, Karbstein, Kevin, Rahmsdorf, Elisabeth

2020

Overview

The larger distribution area of asexuals compared with their sexual relatives in geographical parthenogenesis (GP) scenarios has been widely attributed to the advantages of uniparental reproduction and polyploidy. However, potential disadvantages of sexuals due to their breeding system have received little attention so far. Here, we study the breeding system of five narrowly distributed sexual lineages of Ranunculus notabilis s.l. (R. auricomus complex) and its effects on outcrossing, inbreeding, female fitness, and heterozygosity. We performed selfing and intra‐ and interlineage crossings by bagging 481 flowers (59 garden individuals) followed by germination experiments. We compared seed set and germination rates, and related them to genetic distance and genome‐wide heterozygosity (thousands of RADseq loci). Selfings (2.5%) unveiled a significantly lower seed set compared with intra‐ (69.0%) and interlineage crossings (69.5%). Seed set of intra‐ (65%) compared to interpopulation crossings (78%) was significantly lower. In contrast, all treatments showed comparable germination rates (32%–43%). Generalized linear regressions between seed set and genetic distance revealed positive relationships in general and between lineages, and a negative one within lineages. Seed set was the main decisive factor for female fitness. Germination rates were not related to genetic distance at any level, but were positively associated with heterozygosity in interlineage crossings. Experiments confirmed full crossability and predominant outcrossing among sexual R. notabilis s.l. lineages. However, up to 5% (outliers 15%–31%) of seeds were formed by selfing, probably due to semi‐self‐compatibility in a multi‐locus gametophytic SI system. Less seed set in intrapopulation crossings, and higher seed set and germination rates from crossings of genetically more distant and heterozygous lineages (interlineage) indicate negative inbreeding and positive outbreeding effects. In GP scenarios, sexual species with small and/or isolated populations can suffer from decreased female fitness due to their breeding system. This factor, among others, probably limits range expansion of sexuals. Potential disadvantages of sexual plant species due to their breeding system have received little attention in geographical parthenogenesis (GP) scenarios so far. We compared seed set and germination rates of five sexual lineages of Ranunculus notabilis s.l (R. auricomus complex) and related them to genetic distance and genome‐wide heterozygosity. Results suggest that inbreeding depression particularly affects intrapopulation (intralineage) crossings, and that positive outbreeding effects particularly influence interlineage crossings. In GP scenarios, sexual species with small and/or isolated populations can suffer from decreased female fitness due to their breeding system.

• Publisher: John Wiley & Sons, Inc,John Wiley and Sons Inc,Wiley
• Subject: Asexuality / Diploids / experimental crossings / Females / Fitness / Flowers & plants / Genetic distance / genetic distances / Genetic diversity / Genomes / genome‐wide heterozygosity / Germination / Heterozygosity / Inbreeding / Loci / Original Research / Outbreeding / outcrossing / Parthenogenesis / Plant reproduction / Polyploidy / RADseq / Range extension / Ranunculus auricomus / Ranunculus auricomus / Reproduction (biology) / Reproductive fitness / Seed set / Seeds / selfing