Journal Article

Systematic comparison of variant calling pipelines using gold standard personal exome variants

Marcotte, Edward M., Hwang, Sohyun, Kim, Eiru, Lee, Insuk

2015

Overview

The success of clinical genomics using next generation sequencing (NGS) requires the accurate and consistent identification of personal genome variants. Assorted variant calling methods have been developed, which show low concordance between their calls. Hence, a systematic comparison of the variant callers could give important guidance to NGS-based clinical genomics. Recently, a set of high-confident variant calls for one individual (NA12878) has been published by the Genome in a Bottle (GIAB) consortium, enabling performance benchmarking of different variant calling pipelines. Based on the gold standard reference variant calls from GIAB, we compared the performance of thirteen variant calling pipelines, testing combinations of three read aligners—BWA-MEM, Bowtie2 and Novoalign—and four variant callers—Genome Analysis Tool Kit HaplotypeCaller (GATK-HC), Samtools mpileup, Freebayes and Ion Proton Variant Caller (TVC), for twelve data sets for the NA12878 genome sequenced by different platforms including Illumina2000, Illumina2500 and Ion Proton, with various exome capture systems and exome coverage. We observed different biases toward specific types of SNP genotyping errors by the different variant callers. The results of our study provide useful guidelines for reliable variant identification from deep sequencing of personal genomes.

• Publisher: Nature Publishing Group UK,Nature Publishing Group
• Subject: 631/114/2785 / 631/208/2489 / Base Sequence / Exome - genetics / Genetic Variation / Genomes / Genomics / Genotyping / Genotyping Techniques - methods / Genotyping Techniques - standards / High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing / Humanities and Social Sciences / Humans / multidisciplinary / Pipelines / Polymorphism, Single Nucleotide - genetics / Reference Standards / Science / Single-nucleotide polymorphism