Journal Article

Negotiating grey areas: an interview-based analysis of paramedic uncertainty and decision-making in cardiac arrest events

Fothergill, Rachael, Perkins, Gavin D., Smyth, Michael A., Gardiner, Galina, Huxley, Caroline J., Eli, Karin, Slowther, Anne-Marie, Griffiths, Frances

2024

Overview

Background Paramedics are responsible for critical resuscitation decisions when attending Out of Hospital Cardiac Arrests (OHCA). Existing research indicates that a range of clinical and non-clinical factors moderate their decision-making. Within the United Kingdom (UK), there is little evidence on how and why paramedics make their decisions at actual OHCA events. Methods We explored the experiences of UK paramedics using individually recalled OHCA events as catalysts for discussion. Pen portraits developed from semi-structured interviews with 31 paramedics across two UK ambulance services were thematically analysed, enabling cross-participant comparisons whilst retaining depth and context. Results We identified four themes: uncertainties encountered in resuscitation guidelines, influences on decision-making, holistic perspectives, and indirect moderators. We found that paramedics experienced uncertainty at all stages of the resuscitation process. Uncertainties arose from indeterminate, ambiguous or complex information and were described as having both clinical and ethical dimensions. Whilst guidelines drove paramedics’ decisions, non-clinical personal, practical and relational factors moderated their assessments of survivability and decision-making, with attitudes to interactions between patient age, frailty and quality of life playing a substantial role. Coping strategies such as uncertainty reduction, assumption-based reasoning and weighing pros and cons were evident from interviews. Conclusions The complexity of interactions between clinical and non-clinical factors points to an element of variability in paramedics’ responses to uncertainty. Exploring UK paramedics’ uncertainties and decision-making during specific OHCA events can help acknowledge and address uncertainties in resuscitation guidelines and paramedic training, providing paramedics with the tools to manage uncertainty in a consistent and transparent way.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adult / Allied Health Personnel / Attitude of Health Personnel / Cardiac arrest / Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation / Catalysts / Clinical decision making / Decision Making / Emergency medical services / Emergency Medical Technicians - psychology / Emergency Medicine / Female / Heart / Humans / Information processing / Interviews / Interviews as Topic / Male / Medical prognosis / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Middle Aged / Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest - therapy / Paramedic / Paramedics / Patients / Psychologists / Qualitative Research / Quality of life / Resuscitation / Uncertainty / United Kingdom