Journal Article

A Pragmatic Approach to Assess the Exposure of the Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) When Subjected to Pesticide Spray

Fusellier, Marion, Tchamitchian, Sylvie, Brunet, Jean-Luc, Bodin, Laurent, Lafay, Florent, Giroud, Barbara, Buleté, Audrey, Belzunces, Luc P., Pélissier, Michel, Poquet, Yannick, Tchamitchian, Marc, Cousin, Marianne

2014

Overview

Plant protection spray treatments may expose non-target organisms to pesticides. In the pesticide registration procedure, the honey bee represents one of the non-target model species for which the risk posed by pesticides must be assessed on the basis of the hazard quotient (HQ). The HQ is defined as the ratio between environmental exposure and toxicity. For the honey bee, the HQ calculation is not consistent because it corresponds to the ratio between the pesticide field rate (in mass of pesticide/ha) and LD50 (in mass of pesticide/bee). Thus, in contrast to all other species, the HQ can only be interpreted empirically because it corresponds to a number of bees/ha. This type of HQ calculation is due to the difficulty in transforming pesticide field rates into doses to which bees are exposed. In this study, we used a pragmatic approach to determine the apparent exposure surface area of honey bees submitted to pesticide treatments by spraying with a Potter-type tower. The doses received by the bees were quantified by very efficient chemical analyses, which enabled us to determine an apparent surface area of 1.05 cm(2)/bee. The apparent surface area was used to calculate the exposure levels of bees submitted to pesticide sprays and then to revisit the HQ ratios with a calculation mode similar to that used for all other living species. X-tomography was used to assess the physical surface area of a bee, which was 3.27 cm(2)/bee, and showed that the apparent exposure surface was not overestimated. The control experiments showed that the toxicity induced by doses calculated with the exposure surface area was similar to that induced by treatments according to the European testing procedure. This new approach to measure risk is more accurate and could become a tool to aid the decision-making process in the risk assessment of pesticides.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Agricultural spraying / Agrochemicals / Analytical chemistry / Animals / Apis mellifera / Bees / Bees - drug effects / Bees - physiology / Biology and Life Sciences / Body Surface Area - veterinary / Chemical analysis / Chemical Sciences / Chromatography, Gas / Councils / Decision making / Ecology and Environmental Sciences / Environmental Exposure / European honeybee / Exposure / Food contamination & poisoning / Food safety / Honey / Hymenoptera / Insecticides / Lethal Dose 50 / Models, Theoretical / Organisms / Pesticides / Pesticides - analysis / Pesticides - toxicity / Plant protection / Risk assessment / Species / Sprayers / Spraying / Sprays / Surface area / Toxicity