Journal Article

Real-time forecasting of COVID-19 spread according to protective behavior and vaccination: autoregressive integrated moving average models

Jiang, Wei-Ming, Chang, Hsiao-Han, Cheng, Chieh, Wu, Hsiao-Yu, Cheng, Yu-Chieh, Tsou, Hsiao-Hui, Hsu, Ya-Ting, Fan, Byron

2023

Overview

Background Mathematical and statistical models are used to predict trends in epidemic spread and determine the effectiveness of control measures. Automatic regressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) models are used for time-series forecasting, but only few models of the 2019 coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic have incorporated protective behaviors or vaccination, known to be effective for pandemic control. Methods To improve the accuracy of prediction, we applied newly developed ARIMA models with predictors (mask wearing, avoiding going out, and vaccination) to forecast weekly COVID-19 case growth rates in Canada, France, Italy, and Israel between January 2021 and March 2022. The open-source data was sourced from the YouGov survey and Our World in Data. Prediction performance was evaluated using the root mean square error (RMSE) and the corrected Akaike information criterion (AICc). Results A model with mask wearing and vaccination variables performed best for the pandemic period in which the Alpha and Delta viral variants were predominant (before November 2021). A model using only past case growth rates as autoregressive predictors performed best for the Omicron period (after December 2021). The models suggested that protective behaviors and vaccination are associated with the reduction of COVID-19 case growth rates, with booster vaccine coverage playing a particularly vital role during the Omicron period. For example, each unit increase in mask wearing and avoiding going out significantly reduced the case growth rate during the Alpha/Delta period in Canada (–0.81 and –0.54, respectively; both p < 0.05). In the Omicron period, each unit increase in the number of booster doses resulted in a significant reduction of the case growth rate in Canada (–0.03), Israel (–0.12), Italy (–0.02), and France (–0.03); all p < 0.05. Conclusions The key findings of this study are incorporating behavior and vaccination as predictors led to accurate predictions and highlighted their significant role in controlling the pandemic. These models are easily interpretable and can be embedded in a “real-time” schedule with weekly data updates. They can support timely decision making about policies to control dynamically changing epidemics.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Automatic control / Autoregressive models / Behavior / Biostatistics / Control / Coronaviruses / COVID-19 / COVID-19 - epidemiology / COVID-19 - prevention & control / COVID-19 vaccines / Decision making / Dengue fever / Disease control / Disease transmission / Environmental Health / Epidemics / Epidemiology / Error correction / Fatalities / Forecasting / Forecasts and trends / Growth rate / Health aspects / Humans / Immunization / Longitudinal studies / Machine learning / Mathematical models / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Models, Statistical / Nonpharmaceutical intervention / Pandemics / Pandemics - prevention & control / Performance prediction / Predictions / Prevention / Protective behavior / Public Health / Real time / regARIMA / Regression analysis / Research design / Root-mean-square errors / SARS-CoV-2 / Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 / Social distancing / Statistical analysis / Statistical models / Time series / Trends / Vaccine / Vaccines / Viral diseases