Journal Article

Holding and rupture: Describing post-traumatic stress among former UK Army and Royal Marine personnel deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan

Busuttil, Walter, Simms, Amos, Palmer, Laura, Fear, Nicola T., Stevelink, Sharon A. M.

2024

Overview

Former UK military personnel who were previously deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan in combat roles have exhibited elevated levels of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) compared to other groups. The present qualitative analyses used semi-structured interviews and a framework analysis to compare the experiences of symptomatic (N=10) and asymptomatic (N=7) former Army and Royal Marine personnel who were exposed to combat. Participants were drawn from a large UK military health and wellbeing cohort study and were sampled based upon probable PTSD status using scores from the PTSD Checklist-Civilian Version (PCL-C). All symptomatic participants attributed the development of post-traumatic stress to deployment events, with one additionally ascribing symptoms to childhood events. Among the participants, post-traumatic stress was temporarily buffered, and held at bay, by the holding function of various military structures, including the military collective; cultural and ethical frameworks that helped to organise traumatic experiences; an operational necessity for psychological compartmentalisation and even the distraction of deployment itself. Leaving the military appeared to elicit a global rupture of these supports. As a result, the military-to-civilian transition led to an intensification of post-traumatic stress, including deployment-related memories, among the symptomatic participants. In contrast, asymptomatic participants tended to report continuity of their holding structures across the lifespan, especially across the military-to-civilian transition. The onset and maintenance of post-traumatic stress may thus be explained by an interplay between the capacity of holding structures and the magnitude of lifetime rupture . Overall, findings might provide an explanation for the widening discrepancies between those with enduring post-traumatic stress and those without and further research is required to determine the fit of our findings for other groups and contexts. This approach further illustrates the need to situate individual experiences of post-traumatic stress in wider structural, ecological, cultural and ethical contexts.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Adult / Afghan Campaign 2001 / Armed forces / Asymptomatic / Children / Cohort analysis / Data collection / Ethics / Female / Humans / Interviews / Iraq War, 2003-2011 / Life span / Male / Mental disorders / Mental health / Middle Aged / Military / Military deployment / Military Deployment - psychology / Military personnel / Military Personnel - psychology / Military psychology / Post traumatic stress disorder / Psychological stress / Qualitative analysis / Qualitative research / Rupture / Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic - epidemiology / Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic - psychology / Trauma / United Kingdom - epidemiology