Journal Article

Intermittent fetal heart rate monitoring using a fetoscope or hand held Doppler in rural Tanzania: a randomized controlled trial

Kidanto, Hussein, Mdoe, Paschal Francis, Ersdal, Hege L., Moshiro, Robert, Mduma, Estomih R., Perlman, Jeffrey M., Wangwe, Peter T.

2018

Overview

Background Neonatal mortality is a global challenge, with an estimated 1.3 million intrapartum stillbirths in 2015. The majority of these were found in low resource settings with limited options to intrapartum fetal heart monitoring devices. This trial compared frequency of abnormal fetal heart rate (FHR) detection and adverse perinatal outcomes (i.e. fresh stillbirths, 24-h neonatal deaths, admission to neonatal care unit) among women intermittently assessed by Doppler or fetoscope in a rural low-resource setting. Methods This was an open-label randomized controlled trial conducted at Haydom Lutheran Hospital from March 2013 through August 2015. Inclusion criteria were; women in labor, singleton, cephalic presentation, normal FHR on admission (120–160 beats/minute), and cervical dilatation ≤7 cm. Verbal consent was obtained. Results A total of 2684 women were recruited, 1309 in the Doppler and 1375 in the fetoscope arms, respectively. Abnormal FHR was detected in 55 (4.2%) vs 42 (3.1%). (RR = 1.38; 95%CI: 0.93, 2.04) in the Doppler and fetoscope arms, respectively. Bag mask ventilation was performed in 80 (6.1%) vs 82 (6.0%). (RR = 1.03; 95%CI: 0.76, 1.38) of neonates, and adverse perinatal outcome was comparable 32(2.4%) vs 35(2.5%). (RR = 0.9; 95%CI: 0.59, 1.54), in the Doppler and fetoscope arms, respectively. Conclusion This trial failed to demonstrate a statistically significant difference in the detection of abnormal FHR between intermittently used Doppler and fetoscope and adverse perinatal outcomes. However, FHR measurements were not performed as often as recommended by international guidelines. Conducting a randomized controlled study in rural settings with limited resources is associated with major challenges. Trial registration This clinical trial was registered on April 2013 with registration number NCT01869582 .

• Publisher: BioMed Central,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adolescent / Adult / Apgar Score / Cardiotocography - methods / Childbirth & labor / Clinical trials / Developing Countries / Doppler / Evidence-based medicine / Female / Fetal Distress - diagnosis / Fetal Distress - therapy / Fetoscopy / Fetuses / Gynecology / Heart rate / Heart Rate Determination - methods / Heart Rate, Fetal / Humans / Hypoxia / Infant, Newborn / Intermittent fetal heart rate monitoring / Male / Maternal and Child Health / Medical referrals / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Midwifery / Obstetrics / Pinard fetoscope / Pregnancy / Pregnancy and childbirth in low and middle income countries / Reproductive Medicine / Research Article / Rural health care / Rural Health Services / Stillbirth / Tanzania / Ultrasonography, Doppler / Womens health / Young Adult