Journal Article

Rethinking causal assumptions about maternal BMI, gestational weight gain, and adverse pregnancy outcomes

Mitchell, Megan, Dodd, Jodie M., Louise, Jennie, Poston, Lucilla, Deussen, Andrea R.

2024

Overview

Background The aim of this study was to evaluate commonly assumed causal relationships between body mass index (BMI), gestational weight gain (GWG), and adverse pregnancy outcomes, which have formed the basis of guidelines and interventions aimed at limiting GWG in women with overweight or obesity. We explored relationships between maternal BMI, total GWG (as a continuous variable and as ‘excessive’ GWG), and pregnancy outcomes (including infant birthweight measures and caesarean birth). Methods Analysis of individual participant data (IPD) from the i-WIP (International Weight Management in Pregnancy) Collaboration, from randomised trials of diet and/or physical activity interventions during pregnancy reporting GWG and maternal and neonatal outcomes. Women randomised to the control arm of 20 eligible randomised trials (4370 of 8908 participants) from the i-WIP dataset of 36 randomised trials (total 12,240 women). The main research questions were to characterise the relationship between maternal BMI and (a) total GWG, (b) the risk of ‘excessive’ GWG (using the Institute of Medicine’s guidelines), and (c) adverse pregnancy outcomes as mediated via GWG versus other pathways to determine the extent to which the observed effect of maternal BMI on pregnancy outcomes is mediated via GWG. We utilised generalised linear models and regression-based mediation analyses within an IPD meta-analysis framework. Results Mean GWG decreased linearly as maternal BMI increased; however, the risk of ‘excessive’ GWG increased markedly at BMI category thresholds (i.e. between the normal and overweight BMI category threshold and between the overweight and obese BMI category threshold). Increasing maternal BMI was associated with increased risk of all pregnancy outcomes assessed; however, there was no evidence that this effect was mediated via effects on GWG. Conclusions There is evidence of a meaningful relationship between maternal BMI and GWG and between maternal BMI and adverse pregnancy outcomes. There is no evidence that the effect of maternal BMI on outcomes is via an effect on GWG. Our analyses also cast doubt on the existence of a relationship between ‘excessive’ GWG and adverse pregnancy outcomes. Our findings challenge the practice of actively managing GWG throughout pregnancy.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adult / Analysis / Biomedicine / Birth weight / Body Mass Index / Body size / Body weight / Body weight gain / Causal pathways / Collaboration / Computer software industry / Demographic aspects / Diet / Dietary and lifestyle intervention / Exercise / Female / Gestational age / Gestational weight gain / Gestational Weight Gain - physiology / Guidelines / Health aspects / Humans / Mediation / Mediators / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Missing data / Neonates / Obesity / Obesity - complications / Obesity - physiopathology / Overweight / Physical activity / Physical fitness / Pregnancy / Pregnancy Complications / Pregnancy Outcome / Pregnancy, Complications of / Pregnant women / Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic / Regression analysis / Research Article / Risk / Risk factors / Standard scores / Variables / Weight control / Weight gain / Women