Journal Article

Cognitive biases encountered by physicians in the emergency room

Kunitomo, Kotaro, Watari, Takashi, Harada, Taku

2022

Overview

Background Diagnostic errors constitute an important medical safety problem that needs improvement, and their frequency and severity are high in emergency room settings. Previous studies have suggested that diagnostic errors occur in 0.6-12% of first-time patients in the emergency room and that one or more cognitive factors are involved in 96% of these cases. This study aimed to identify the types of cognitive biases experienced by physicians in emergency rooms in Japan. Methods We conducted a questionnaire survey using Nikkei Medical Online (Internet) from January 21 to January 31, 2019. Of the 159,519 physicians registered with Nikkei Medical Online when the survey was administered, those who volunteered their most memorable diagnostic error cases in the emergency room participated in the study. EZR was used for the statistical analyses. Results A total of 387 physicians were included. The most common cognitive biases were overconfidence (22.5%), confirmation (21.2%), availability (12.4%), and anchoring (11.4%). Of the error cases, the top five most common initial diagnoses were upper gastrointestinal disease (22.7%), trauma (14.7%), cardiovascular disease (10.9%), respiratory disease (7.5%), and primary headache (6.5%). The corresponding final diagnoses for these errors were intestinal obstruction or peritonitis (27.3%), overlooked traumas (47.4%), other cardiovascular diseases (66.7%), cardiovascular disease (41.4%), and stroke (80%), respectively. Conclusions A comparison of the initial and final diagnoses of cases with diagnostic errors shows that there were more cases with diagnostic errors caused by overlooking another disease in the same organ or a disease in a closely related organ.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Analysis / Bias / Cardiovascular disease / Cardiovascular diseases / Cognitive ability / Cognitive biases / Decision making / Diagnostic error / Emergency medical care / Emergency Medicine / Emergency service / Gastrointestinal diseases / Hospitals / Medical diagnosis / Medical error / Medical errors / Medical safety / Medicine / Medicine & Public Health / Patients / Peritonitis / Physicians / Questionnaires / Respiratory diseases / Respiratory tract diseases / Set (Psychology) / Shift work / Statistical analysis / Surveys / Trauma