Journal Article

Comparison of breast cancer surrogate subtyping using a closed-system RT-qPCR breast cancer assay and immunohistochemistry on 100 core needle biopsies with matching surgical specimens

Janeva, Slavica, Kovács, Anikó, Nasic, Salmir, Parris, Toshima Z., Larsson, Karolina, Audisio, Riccardo A., De Lara, Shahin, Olofsson Bagge, Roger

2021

Overview

Background Routine clinical management of breast cancer (BC) currently depends on surrogate subtypes according to estrogen- (ER) and progesterone (PR) receptor, Ki-67, and HER2-status. However, there has been growing demand for reduced immunohistochemistry (IHC) turnaround times. The Xpert® Breast Cancer STRAT4* Assay (STRAT4)*, a standardized test for ESR1 / PGR / MKi67 / ERBB2 mRNA biomarker assessment, takes less than 2 hours. Here, we compared the concordance between the STRAT4 and IHC/SISH, thereby evaluating the effect of method choice on surrogate subtype assessment and adjuvant treatment decisions. Methods In total, 100 formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded core needle biopsy (CNB) samples and matching surgical specimens for 98 patients with primary invasive BC were evaluated using the STRAT4 assay. The concordance between STRAT4 and IHC was calculated for individual markers for the CNB and surgical specimens. In addition, we investigated whether changes in surrogate BC subtyping based on the STRAT4 results would change adjuvant treatment recommendations. Results The overall percent agreement (OPA) between STRAT4 and IHC/SISH ranged between 76 and 99% for the different biomarkers. Concordance for all four biomarkers in the surgical specimens and CNBs was only 66 and 57%, respectively. In total, 74% of surgical specimens were concordant for subtype, regardless of the method used. IHC- and STRAT4-based subtyping for the surgical specimen were shown to be discordant for 25/98 patients and 18/25 patients would theoretically have been recommended a different adjuvant treatment, primarily receiving more chemotherapy and trastuzumab. Conclusions A comparison of data from IHC/in situ hybridization and STRAT4 demonstrated that subsequent changes in surrogate subtyping for the surgical specimen may theoretically result in more adjuvant treatment given, primarily with chemotherapy and trastuzumab.

• Publisher: BioMed Central,BioMed Central Ltd,Springer Nature B.V,BMC
• Subject: Adult / Aged / Aged, 80 and over / Automation / Biomarkers / Biomarkers, Tumor / Biomedical and Life Sciences / Biomedicine / Biopsy / Biopsy, Large-Core Needle - methods / Biopsy, Large-Core Needle - standards / Biopsy, Needle / Breast cancer / Breast cancer biomarker assay / Breast cancer biomarker assays / Breast Neoplasms - diagnosis / Breast Neoplasms - etiology / Breast Neoplasms - metabolism / Breast Neoplasms - surgery / Cancer and Oncology / Cancer och onkologi / Cancer Research / Chemotherapy / Cloning / Comparative analysis / Diagnosis / ErbB-2 protein / Estrogen receptors / Female / Gene expression / Health Promotion and Disease Prevention / Humans / Hybridization / Identification and classification / Immunohistochemistry / Immunohistochemistry - methods / Immunohistochemistry - standards / Invasiveness / Mastectomy - methods / Medicine/Public Health / Middle Aged / Monoclonal antibodies / mRNA / Oncology / Paraffin / Pathology / Patients / PCR / Polymerase chain reaction / Progesterone / Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction - methods / Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction - standards / Reproducibility of Results / Sensitivity and Specificity / STRAT4 / Surgical Oncology / Surrogate subtyping / Trastuzumab