Journal Article

What is replication?

Nosek, Brian A., Errington, Timothy M.

2020

Overview

Credibility of scientific claims is established with evidence for their replicability using new data. According to common understanding, replication is repeating a study's procedure and observing whether the prior finding recurs. This definition is intuitive, easy to apply, and incorrect. We propose that replication is a study for which any outcome would be considered diagnostic evidence about a claim from prior research. This definition reduces emphasis on operational characteristics of the study and increases emphasis on the interpretation of possible outcomes. The purpose of replication is to advance theory by confronting existing understanding with new evidence. Ironically, the value of replication may be strongest when existing understanding is weakest. Successful replication provides evidence of generalizability across the conditions that inevitably differ from the original study; Unsuccessful replication indicates that the reliability of the finding may be more constrained than recognized previously. Defining replication as a confrontation of current theoretical expectations clarifies its important, exciting, and generative role in scientific progress.

• Publisher: Public Library of Science,Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subject: Biology and Life Sciences / Data Interpretation, Statistical / Diagnostic systems / Earthquakes / Humans / Hypotheses / Medicine and Health Sciences / Methods / Open access / Repeated measures (Research method) / Replication / Reproducibility / Reproducibility of Results / Research and Analysis Methods / Research Design - standards / Research Design - statistics & numerical data / Research validity / Researchers / Social Sciences / Statistics as Topic / Studies / Theory