Journal Article

Dimensions over categories: a meta-analysis of taxometric research

McGrath, Melanie J., Haslam, Nick, Viechtbauer, Wolfgang, Kuppens, Peter

2020

Overview

Taxometric procedures have been used extensively to investigate whether individual differences in personality and psychopathology are latently dimensional or categorical (‘taxonic’). We report the first meta-analysis of taxometric research, examining 317 findings drawn from 183 articles that employed an index of the comparative fit of observed data to dimensional and taxonic data simulations. Findings supporting dimensional models outnumbered those supporting taxonic models five to one. There were systematic differences among 17 construct domains in support for the two models, but psychopathology was no more likely to generate taxonic findings than normal variation (i.e. individual differences in personality, response styles, gender, and sexuality). No content domain showed aggregate support for the taxonic model. Six variables – alcohol use disorder, intermittent explosive disorder, problem gambling, autism, suicide risk, and pedophilia – emerged as the most plausible taxon candidates based on a preponderance of independently replicated findings. We also compared the 317 meta-analyzed findings to 185 additional taxometric findings from 96 articles that did not employ the comparative fit index. Studies that used the index were 4.88 times more likely to generate dimensional findings than those that did not after controlling for construct domain, implying that many taxonic findings obtained before the popularization of simulation-based techniques are spurious. The meta-analytic findings support the conclusion that the great majority of psychological differences between people are latently continuous, and that psychopathology is no exception.

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Subject: Alcohol related disorders / Alcohol use / Alcoholism / Autism / Candidates / Drinking behavior / Gambling / Humans / Indexes / Individual differences / Intermittent / Mental Disorders - classification / Mental Disorders - diagnosis / Meta-analysis / Pathological gambling / Pedophilia / Personality / Personality Assessment / Personality disorders / Personality Disorders - classification / Personality Disorders - diagnosis / Psychopathology / Research Design / Sexuality / Simulation / Suicide / Systematic review / Variables